Taxi Fares Held Level For Another 18 Months In Highland And Tuk Tuk Licence For Wick Refused

18th February 2020

Photograph of Taxi Fares Held Level For Another 18 Months In Highland And Tuk Tuk Licence For Wick Refused

Following a review taxi fares in Highland have been held at the same level by the Highland Council Licensing Committee held on 18 February 2019.

The papers and the debate on this issue can be seen at items six on the webcast -

https://highland.public-i.tv/core/portal/webcast_interactive/469655

There is a 14 Day period for appeal.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

At the same meeting the committee at Item 7 were asked if they would licence a Tuk Tuk vehicle as private hire car after an application by a member of the public had asked. The application was from Mr Amin, Wick, Caithness. The application was refused by the committee.

The police objected and submitted a letter -

Dear Sir/Madam

CIVIC GOVERNMENT (SCOTLAND) ACT 1982 SECTION 10(2)

SUITABILITY OF A TUK-TUK AS A TAXI OR PRIVATE HIRE VEHICLE

POLICE OBJECTION

I have been informed by the Highland Council that a Tuk-Tuk is currently being operated in Wick, and that the operator, Mr. Rehan Amin, wishes the vehicle to be licensed as a Taxi or Private Hire Vehicle.

I am aware that the operator has been informed by the Highland Council that the Tuk-Tuk does not meet the Council's specification with respect to its size, type and design. However, Mr. Amin has requested that the Licensing Committee consider a report that the Tuk-Tuk be considered suitable as a Taxi/Private Hire Vehicle.

I am of the opinion that the design and operation of a Tuk-Tuk deems it as an inappropriate and unsuitable vehicle to be used as a Taxi or Private Hire Vehicle, and on the grounds of public safety, I would object to any proposal to licence Tuk-Tuks by the Highland Council for this purpose.

I have consulted with Inspector Donald Mackinnon from the Roads Policing Department in the Highlands & Islands Division. He is also of the opinion that a Tuk-Tuk is not suitable for use as a Taxi or Private Hire Vehicle. He has provided the following response:

Taking into account the following considerations, I do not recommend Tuk-Tuk use for taxi/private hire business.

Background

The Tuk-Tuk, also known as an Auto Rickshaw, is a motorised development of the traditional pulled or cycle rickshaw. The most common version comprises of a sheetmetal body or an open frame resting on three wheels. They have a canvas roof with drop down side curtains. There is normally a small cabin for the driver with handlebar controls, and another compartment in the rear for passengers. They are most popular in countries with tropical and sub-tropical climates and in particular, developing

countries.

Safety concerns

Some of the safety issues with the Tuk-Tuk are due to their type, size and design.

Due to the Tuk-Tuk having only 3 road wheels and a relatively short narrow wheel base, there are concerns regarding stability which is easily compromised whilst negotiating roundabouts and various corners within built-up/residential areas. If the Tuk-Tuk approached and attempted to negotiate these hazards at an inappropriate

speed, it would be susceptible to tipping over.

There is little protection afforded to the occupants of a Tuk-Tuk, with the only cover being a canvas roof in this case. Safety features are virtually non-existent with no airbags and no side protection other than the canvas or metal sheet. These are vital safety features that protect occupants of vehicles in road traffic collisions and in turn

reduce the number of casualties on our roads.

Tuk-Tuks are generally only fitted with lap belts due to their very compact nature, there is little room between the passengers and the vehicle extremities. Therefore if a Tuk-Tuk is involved in a road traffic collision, there is a greater potential for the occupants to be seriously injured or killed.

There is also a concern surrounding the lack of lighting on Tuk-Tuks which may make them difficult for other road users to see. Areas with limited or poor street lighting will increase the risk to the occupants.

Given the nature of the taxi/private hire business, some passengers/customers will be more vulnerable due to their age, size or demeanour. Some may be affected by alcohol and therefore are at a greater risk of falling from the Tuk-Tuk. Given the fact

that the top speed can reach in excess of 40mph, falling from the vehicle at this speed could have devastating consequences.

In addition, I understand that the operator intends to utilise his Tuk-Tuk on roads along the North Coast 500 route as a licensed taxi, and as such, I would also have concerns that the vehicle could cause obstructions on an already very busy road network due to its limited speed. This, in turn could potentially increase the risk of a road traffic accident.

I am also aware that a similar proposal was brought before the Licensing Committee in Dumfries & Galloway in 2019, which was refused by Committee members, and I would urge the Highland Council Licensing Committee to also refuse any application in relation to this proposal on the grounds of public safety, and the vehicle not being for purpose.

Should the Committee agree to the licensing of Tuk-Tuks as taxis or private hire vehicles, then any subsequent applications submitted for such vehicles to be licensed will be the subject of a police objection, on the grounds of public safety, and the vehicle not being fit for purpose.

Yours sincerely

 

Related Businesses

 

Related Articles

Yesterday : Local Authority

UK Shared Prosperity Fund investment helps grow green skills in the Highlands

Investment through the UK Shared Prosperity Fund is helping UHI Inverness expand access to green skills training and new technologies, supporting the workforce needed for the Highlands' transition to a low carbon economy.   A total of £220,000 of UK Shared Prosperity Fund support has been awarded towards a £234,000 programme, covering three linked projects: green skills training, Solar PV installation, and the purchase of augmented and virtual reality welding equipment.  

17/11/2026 : Local Authority

New Members of the Scottish Youth Parliament elected for Highland

The Scottish Youth Parliament (SYP) has welcomed five new Highland members and one continuing member following the outcome of recent elections.   Members of the Scottish Youth Parliament (MSYP) are elected every two years and become the voice of Scotland's young people.  

16/11/2026 : Advisory / Counseling Services

The People Building Caithness's Future: Meet the Local Entrepreneurs Making Things Happen

When people discuss the future of Caithness, attention often turns to major employers, government investment, renewable energy developments and the search for new industries.   All of these matter.  

16/11/2026 : Local Authority

Caithness Has More to Celebrate Than We Sometimes Realise

Caithness has become accustomed to reading about economic difficulties, declining public services, empty shops, rising costs and the challenges facing rural communities.  These are important issues and should not be ignored.  

16/11/2026 : Local Authority

The Subscription Society: Are Councils and Publicly Funded Charities Charging Us for Too Much?

Councils across Scotland are under considerable financial pressure.  Rising wages, energy bills, borrowing costs and increasing demand for essential services are leaving local authorities searching for ways to balance their budgets.  

15/11/2026 : Local Authority

Caithness: Are We Becoming Britain's Energy Storage Capital?

Caithness has long been associated with energy production.  From the nuclear industry at Dounreay to the development of onshore wind farms, the area has played an important role in Britain's changing energy requirements.  

15/11/2026 : Local Authority

Highland Rangers Do Valuable Work, But Is a Paid Newsletter the Best Use of Their Time?

Highland's Countryside Ranger Service performs an important role in protecting the natural environment, helping people understand local wildlife and encouraging greater appreciation of the countryside.  Its work with schools, communities, visitors and landowners is valuable, and at a time when environmental pressures are increasing, the contribution of Rangers should not be underestimated.  

15/11/2026 : Local Authority

Caithness at a Crossroads: Investment Opportunities Grow, But Are Essential Services Keeping Pace?

Caithness finds itself in an interesting position.  There are opportunities emerging across energy, infrastructure, harbour development, education and construction.  

14/11/2026 : Local Authority

Highland's £2.1 Billion Investment Gamble: Rising Interest Rates, Construction Costs and Energy Prices Create New Risks

Highland Council's ambitious 20-year investment programme was designed to modernise schools, roads and public buildings.  But higher borrowing costs, construction inflation and rising energy prices are raising questions about whether the original financial assumptions will still stand up.  

13/11/2026 : Local Authority

Almost £500,000 awarded to community transport groups across the Highlands

Community transport groups across the Highlands have been awarded grants totalling £498,000 to support local transport services in 2027/28.   The grants will support 34 community transport providers, including seven new recipients, whose services play a vital role in helping people access services, connecting communities and addressing local transport challenges.