2nd November 2026
Britain spends a great deal of time worrying about government borrowing. Every Budget brings renewed arguments about the national debt, public spending, taxation and whether the country can afford to borrow more. Politicians regularly warn that government debt is becoming unsustainable and that future generations will have to pay the price.
But there is another debt problem that receives considerably less attention. It is the debt accumulated by households and businesses, borrowed from banks, building societies, finance companies, investment funds and other lenders.
This is known as private debt, and it deserves much greater attention in any assessment of Britain's economic health.
Households owe money on mortgages, credit cards, personal loans and car finance. Businesses borrow to invest, expand, buy other companies and maintain their operations. Much of this borrowing is perfectly reasonable and can support economic growth. The danger arises when debt grows faster than incomes, when borrowers struggle to meet repayments, or when businesses become so heavily indebted that rising interest rates leave them with little room to manoeuvre.
The financial crisis of 2008 demonstrated what can happen when private borrowing gets out of control. Yet, nearly two decades later, much of the public debate still concentrates on government debt rather than the financial pressures building up elsewhere in the economy.
The legacy of 2008: have we really learned the lessons?
To understand why private debt matters, it is worth going back to the years preceding the 2008 financial crisis.
During the decade before the crash, British households were encouraged to borrow. Mortgage lending expanded, house prices increased and banks became increasingly willing to provide credit. Rising property values created the impression that households were becoming wealthier, encouraging further borrowing.
The problem was that a significant part of the apparent prosperity depended on continued access to cheap credit and rising house prices.
When the financial crisis arrived, that confidence collapsed. Banks became reluctant to lend, businesses struggled to obtain finance, property prices fell and households began cutting their spending.
The consequences were severe. Banks required government support, unemployment increased and the economy entered a prolonged period of weak growth.
The important lesson was that private borrowing could create an economic boom, but when confidence disappeared, the process could work in reverse. Households and businesses attempted to repay debt at the same time, reducing spending and investment and making the downturn worse.
Economists sometimes describe this as a balance-sheet recession. It is a particularly useful concept because it explains why an economy can struggle to recover even when interest rates are reduced. People who are already heavily indebted may not want to borrow more, however cheap the loans become.
Household debt: the headline figures can be misleading
The historical figures are revealing.
According to the House of Commons Library, household debt increased from around 85% of disposable income in 1996 to a peak of 156.7% in the third quarter of 2008.
Since then, the ratio has declined considerably. By the second quarter of 2026 it stood at 116.5%.
At first sight, this suggests that British households are in a much healthier position than they were before the financial crisis.
There is some truth in that. Households have reduced their overall debt relative to income, lending standards have changed and banks are better capitalised.
However, aggregate statistics can hide considerable differences between households. Someone with a substantial mortgage, secure employment and savings is in a very different position from someone relying on credit cards to pay for food, energy and everyday essentials.
The cost-of-living crisis has also changed the nature of household financial pressure. Higher food prices, rent, energy bills, council tax and mortgage payments have left some families with very little money at the end of the month.
The Office of National Statistics has reported that some households have responded to rising living costs by using more credit than usual. This is a warning sign because borrowing to maintain everyday living standards is very different from borrowing to buy a house or make a productive investment.
The mortgage problem has not disappeared
Mortgage borrowing deserves particular attention because it is usually the largest debt most households will ever take on.
For many years, homeowners became accustomed to relatively cheap mortgages. When interest rates rose sharply after the inflation surge of 2022, those coming to the end of fixed-rate deals faced the prospect of considerably higher monthly repayments.
Not everybody experienced the increase at once. Fixed-rate mortgages delayed the impact for many households, but that also meant that some of the pressure would arrive gradually as existing agreements expired.
The Bank of England's July 2026 Financial Stability Report suggests that household finances remain resilient in aggregate. Mortgage repayments represented around 7.5% of post-tax household income at the end of 2025, with the Bank projecting a modest increase over the following years in its higher-energy-price scenario.
But the Bank also warns that lower-income households are more exposed to increases in borrowing costs and essential living expenses.
This is an important distinction. The economy can look reasonably healthy when viewed through national averages while individual households are experiencing considerable financial hardship.
Business borrowing: a less visible source of risk
Household debt is only half the story. Business borrowing is equally important, particularly when companies are carrying large debts following takeovers, restructuring or years of weak trading.
Businesses borrow for perfectly understandable reasons. They may need new machinery, vehicles, buildings, technology or working capital. Borrowing can allow a successful business to expand more quickly than would otherwise be possible.
But there is a difference between borrowing to invest in the future and borrowing simply to keep an existing business operating.
A company with substantial debt must generate enough income to pay interest and eventually repay or refinance its loans. If energy prices increase, customers reduce spending or interest rates rise, the company's financial position can deteriorate quickly.
Smaller businesses can be particularly vulnerable because they often have less cash available and fewer financing options.
There is also the problem of companies acquired through private equity. These transactions frequently involve substantial borrowing, with the acquired business expected to generate the cash needed to service the debt.
Such arrangements can work well, but they can also leave companies financially stretched. Money that might otherwise have been spent on new equipment, staff, training or expansion can end up paying interest to lenders.
This is one reason why it is important to examine business debt alongside investment and productivity. A country can have businesses that are generating substantial revenues without necessarily investing enough to improve their long-term competitiveness.
The growth of private credit: borrowing outside traditional banks
One of the more interesting developments since 2008 has been the expansion of private credit.
Traditionally, businesses needing finance would approach a bank. Today, an increasing number can obtain loans from investment funds and other non-bank lenders.
Private credit has become a major international market, estimated by the Financial Stability Board at between $1.5 trillion and $2 trillion in assets at the end of 2024.
These funds provide finance that banks might be unwilling or unable to offer. They can be particularly useful for businesses that need more flexible lending arrangements.
However, the expansion also creates new risks.
Private credit is generally less transparent than traditional bank lending. Loans are often negotiated privately rather than traded openly, making it more difficult to establish their true market value.
Some loans carry floating interest rates, meaning that borrowing costs can increase rapidly when central banks raise rates.
There can also be connections between private credit funds, banks, insurance companies and pension investors. A problem in one part of the market can therefore spread to others.
The Bank of England's Financial Policy Committee warned in September 2026 that parts of private credit and other risky lending markets remain vulnerable to tighter financial conditions. It specifically highlighted the difficulties that highly leveraged borrowers could face if interest rates remain higher or economic growth weakens.
The Financial Stability Board has also called for better information about the market, its leverage and the connections between lenders and the wider financial system.
This is an area worth watching because the next financial problem may not originate in the traditional banking system.
[/b]Why the total debt figures do not tell the whole story[/b]
There is an important statistical issue when measuring private debt.
The actual amount borrowed can increase while the debt burden relative to the size of the economy falls.
For example, if household and business borrowing increases by 5% but nominal GDP increases by 10%, private debt becomes a smaller proportion of GDP.
That does not mean borrowers have repaid their loans. It means the economy's measured money value has grown faster than the outstanding debt.
This happened after the pandemic. The Bank of England reported that inflation and rising nominal GDP helped reduce household and corporate debt ratios, even though the actual stock of borrowing continued to increase.
Its December 2025 Financial Stability Report noted that household borrowing had increased by more than £200 billion and corporate borrowing by more than £100 billion since the first half of 2020.
This is particularly important when interpreting Britain's apparent improvement in private debt.
Inflation can make debt look smaller relative to national income without necessarily making the financial position of individual borrowers any easier.
Indeed, households facing sharply higher food, energy and housing costs may find their finances deteriorating even while the national debt-to-income ratio improves.
The consequences for economic growth
Private debt matters because it influences how much money is available to circulate through the economy.
Consider a household whose mortgage repayments increase by £200 a month. That money has to come from somewhere. It may mean fewer visits to local shops, reduced spending on holidays or postponing purchases.
Multiply that across hundreds of thousands of households and the effect on consumer demand can become significant.
Businesses experience a similar problem. A company paying more in interest has less money available for wages, investment and expansion.
There is a knock-on effect for employment, productivity and tax revenues.
This is particularly relevant to areas such as Caithness, where the local economy depends on household spending and the financial health of relatively small businesses. A reduction in disposable income can affect independent retailers, hospitality businesses, tradespeople and other local services.
It is also worth remembering that debt repayments do not all have the same economic consequences. Interest payments made to domestic lenders may remain within the British economy, although they redistribute income from borrowers to lenders. Payments to overseas lenders represent a different leakage from domestic spending.
The wider problem is that excessive debt can leave the economy more vulnerable to shocks and make it harder to recover from a downturn.
The interest-rate dilemma
This brings us back to the Bank of England and the difficult decisions facing monetary policymakers.
If inflation increases because of higher oil, gas and fuel prices, the Bank may consider raising interest rates to prevent inflation becoming embedded in the economy.
But higher interest rates also increase the cost of borrowing.
Households with mortgages, people using credit cards and businesses relying on loans all face additional pressure. Companies with floating-rate borrowing can be affected particularly quickly.
There is a danger that monetary policy intended to control inflation ends up weakening an economy already struggling with high living costs.
Of course, leaving inflation unchecked is not an answer either. Inflation itself damages household savings and purchasing power, and can eventually force interest rates higher for longer.
The Bank therefore has to balance two risks: allowing inflation to persist and creating additional financial pressure through higher borrowing costs.
This is one reason why private debt should feature much more prominently in discussions about interest rates.
Is private debt more dangerous than government debt?
This is perhaps the most interesting question.
Government debt and private debt are fundamentally different. Governments have taxation powers and, in the UK's case, issue debt in a currency controlled by the Bank of England and the wider monetary system. Households and ordinary businesses do not have those options.
A household cannot increase its income by raising taxes. A small business cannot issue its own currency to meet its creditors.
However, this does not mean that government borrowing is without limits or consequences. Interest costs, inflation, market confidence and the government's ability to raise revenue all matter.
The important point is that private debt can create serious economic problems even when government finances appear relatively healthy.
The 2008 financial crisis is the obvious example. Excessive private borrowing and failures in the financial system produced a crisis that governments then had to deal with through bank support, emergency measures and economic stimulus.
There is a further connection with the arguments made by economists such as Steve Keen. He has repeatedly emphasised the relationship between private credit creation, economic growth and financial instability.
His argument is that looking only at government deficits misses a major part of the monetary system. Banks create money when they lend, and rapid expansion of private credit can temporarily stimulate economic activity while building up vulnerabilities.
This is an important contribution to the wider debate about Modern Monetary Theory, government deficits and the role of money creation in the economy.
It does not mean that every increase in private lending leads to a crisis. But it does mean that private credit deserves to be monitored just as carefully as public borrowing.
What is the Bank of England telling us?
It would be wrong to suggest that the Bank of England believes Britain is on the verge of another financial crisis.
Its July 2026 Financial Stability Report actually presents a relatively reassuring picture of household and corporate finances in aggregate. Household debt relative to income has fallen, corporate debt relative to earnings is around its longer-term average, and the banking system is considered sufficiently capitalised to withstand substantial economic shocks.
However, the Bank distinguishes between the overall position and the vulnerabilities among particular borrowers. Lower-income households, smaller businesses and highly leveraged companies remain more exposed.
The September Financial Policy Committee assessment also identifies risks in private credit markets and warns that tighter financial conditions could expose weaknesses.
That is a more balanced conclusion than either claiming that Britain is heading for a debt disaster or assuming that falling debt ratios mean the problem has disappeared.
Keeping a closer watch on Britain's private debt
I think this subject deserves more than a single article. It would be useful to establish a regular assessment of private borrowing, perhaps every three months, using figures from the Bank of England, Office for National Statistics, Bank for International Settlements and other reliable sources.
The most important thing would be to distinguish between the amount of debt outstanding, the rate at which new borrowing is taking place and the ability of borrowers to meet their repayments.
We should watch household mortgage borrowing, credit card balances, personal loans, mortgage arrears, consumer insolvencies and energy debt. For businesses, we should examine corporate borrowing, interest costs, company insolvencies, bank lending and the growing private credit market.
We should also compare the UK with other major economies to see whether Britain's position is improving or deteriorating relative to its competitors.
The Bank for International Settlements is particularly useful because it provides long-running quarterly comparisons of household and corporate borrowing across more than 40 economies.
There is no need to assume that every increase in debt is a warning of trouble. What matters is whether borrowing is becoming unsustainable and whether the economy is increasingly dependent on credit to maintain growth.
Britain's economic health cannot be judged simply by looking at how much the government owes. We also need to know how much households and businesses owe, who is lending the money, what it costs to service that borrowing and what happens when the economy turns against them.
That is a much bigger part of the economic picture than is generally acknowledged.
FSB warns on private credit vulnerabilities
Household debt Economic indicators