3rd November 2026
One of the most striking features of the American midterm elections is that voters are not simply choosing politicians. In many states, they are also voting on proposed laws, changes to their state constitutions and decisions that would normally be left to elected representatives in Britain.
On November 3, 2026, Americans voted on 145 statewide ballot measures across the country. Some dealt with major constitutional questions, others with taxation, education, voting rules, public services and the powers of government.
It is an important difference between the American and British political systems. In Britain, we elect MPs and members of devolved parliaments and assemblies to make laws on our behalf. Direct public votes on individual pieces of legislation are relatively unusual.
In parts of the United States, however, voters can have a much more direct role in making the law.
How does it work?
There are two main ways a proposal can reach the ballot paper.
The first is through the state legislature. State representatives can agree to put a proposed constitutional amendment or other question to voters. The public then decides whether to accept or reject it.
The second is through a citizens' initiative. In states that allow this, campaigners can collect a required number of signatures from registered voters. If they meet the legal requirements, their proposal can be put to a public vote.
This means that a group of citizens can sometimes bypass their state politicians and take an issue directly to the electorate.
The arrangements differ between states. Some allow voters to propose ordinary laws as well as constitutional amendments. Others have more restricted systems, and not every state permits citizens to initiate legislation.
Abortion rights and constitutional change
One of the most politically significant issues in the 2026 elections was abortion.
In Missouri, voters were asked whether to reverse a constitutional protection for reproductive freedom that had been approved by voters in 2024. The proposed restriction was rejected.
Virginia voters, meanwhile, approved a constitutional amendment protecting reproductive freedom, including abortion access during the first two trimesters.
These examples illustrate how voters can be asked to make decisions that have a lasting effect on the law and the rights of individuals.
In Britain, such questions would normally be dealt with through legislation passed by Parliament or the relevant devolved legislature. There is no routine system allowing campaigners to collect signatures and force a national referendum on an ordinary policy proposal.
Taxation and public spending
Other ballot measures involved money and the services provided by local government.
Florida voters approved a substantial expansion of property-tax exemptions for homeowners. Supporters argued that this would reduce household costs, while local authorities raised concerns about the possible effect on their finances.
California had proposals concerning taxation and public spending, including a proposed one-off tax on billionaire wealth and a bond programme to support affordable housing.
These are the kinds of questions that would normally be debated in Parliament, Holyrood or local councils in Britain. American voters can sometimes be asked to decide them directly.
That does not necessarily make the decisions easier. A tax reduction may benefit homeowners but leave councils with less money for services. A new spending commitment may be popular but still require a reliable source of funding.
Voters are being asked to weigh up those consequences, often with competing campaign groups presenting very different arguments.
Who controls the electoral system?
Another important subject was the way elections themselves are organised.
In Missouri, voters rejected a proposed congressional map intended to help Republicans secure an additional seat in the US House of Representatives.
Elsewhere, voters considered proposals concerning voter identification and the rules governing who can participate in elections.
These are not merely administrative matters. The way constituencies are drawn can influence which party has a better opportunity to win representation. Rules on voter registration and identification can also affect how easy it is for people to cast a ballot.
The American system therefore gives voters a direct say in some of the rules that govern their own elections.
A system with advantages and disadvantages
There are obvious attractions to direct democracy.
It gives citizens a way to challenge decisions made by politicians, particularly when an issue has attracted widespread public concern but has not been addressed by the legislature.
It can also force politicians to pay attention. A campaign that gathers enough signatures to secure a referendum may persuade legislators to negotiate or introduce their own compromise rather than face a public vote.
But there are disadvantages too.
Campaigns can be expensive, and wealthy individuals or organisations may have much greater resources to promote their preferred outcome. The wording of a proposal can be complicated, and a simple yes-or-no vote may not adequately explain the financial or legal consequences.
There is also the question of what happens after a vote. A proposal may be approved by the public but then face legal challenges, disputes over implementation or difficulties in finding the money to deliver it.
In some states, legislatures retain powers to amend or repeal laws passed through citizen initiatives. Missouri voters were even asked in 2026 whether to make it harder for lawmakers to change laws introduced by voters.
That is an interesting constitutional question in itself: if the public makes a law directly, how much freedom should its elected representatives have to change it later?
What happens in Britain?
Britain is not without direct democracy. We have held referendums on major constitutional and political questions.
The 2014 Scottish independence referendum, the 2016 EU membership referendum and the 2011 referendum on the voting system are familiar examples. There have also been votes on devolution in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland, as well as local referendums.
However, there is no general requirement for a referendum whenever Parliament proposes a major change to the law. Nor is there a general UK-wide system through which citizens can collect signatures and force a binding vote on a proposed piece of legislation.
The UK Parliament remains sovereign. Even where a referendum takes place, its legal effect depends on the legislation governing that particular vote. Politically, however, governments and Parliament cannot easily disregard a clear public decision.
Scotland has its own Parliament, with responsibility for devolved matters such as health, education, justice and local government. But Scottish voters do not routinely vote directly on individual Bills or proposed changes to Scottish law.
[/b]
[b]Would more direct democracy work here?
There is a reasonable debate to be had about whether Britain should give voters more opportunities to influence legislation between elections.
For example, should a sufficiently large petition on a major issue be able to trigger a public vote? Should voters be able to decide certain questions about local taxation, planning or public services? Could local referendums give communities a stronger voice when councils are considering major changes?
There are practical difficulties. Complex legislation cannot always be reduced to a straightforward yes-or-no question. There would need to be safeguards against misleading campaigns, excessive spending and proposals that conflict with existing legal rights.
Nor should direct democracy become a substitute for parliamentary scrutiny. Elected representatives have a responsibility to examine the detail, assess costs and consider the consequences of legislation.
The American experience offers plenty of examples of both the possibilities and the problems.
But it also raises a question worth considering in Britain. Elections give people the opportunity to choose who governs them. Should they also have more opportunities to decide what those governments actually do?
That is a debate that goes well beyond the American midterms.
Notes
Some of the most significant examples
State / issue What voters were being asked to decide
Missouri – abortion Whether to reverse the abortion-rights protection approved by voters in 2024 and impose new restrictions. Voters rejected the proposed amendment.
Virginia – reproductive rights Whether to add reproductive freedom, including abortion access during the first two trimesters, to the state constitution. Voters approved it.
Missouri – congressional boundaries Whether to accept a revised congressional map designed to help Republicans win an additional House seat. Voters rejected it.
Florida – property taxes Whether to substantially increase the tax exemption for homeowners. The change was approved, although local authorities warned of possible reductions in funding for services.
California – billionaire wealth tax Whether to impose a one-off tax on the wealth of billionaires, with revenue intended to support healthcare.
California – affordable housing Whether to authorise $11.25 billion in bonds to support affordable housing, including homes for veterans, students and farmworkers.
California – income tax Whether to make additional income taxes on high earners permanent, with the proceeds supporting schools and community colleges.
California – voter identification Whether to introduce new government-issued ID requirements for voting. Voters rejected the proposal.
Ohio – voter identification Whether to strengthen existing voter ID requirements by putting them into the state constitution. Voters approved the measure.
North Dakota – school meals Whether public schools should provide every pupil with one free breakfast and one free lunch each school day.
Wisconsin – governor's powers Whether to restrict the governor's ability to use a partial veto to create or increase taxes or fees.
Arizona – traffic cameras Whether to restrict the use of cameras to enforce speeding and red-light rules.