18th November 2026
The promise of taking care of your funeral expenses in advance is an attractive one. Nobody wants to leave their family facing an unexpected bill at an already difficult time. It is hardly surprising, therefore, that funeral plans have become increasingly popular, with companies regularly advertising them on television.
But a developing scandal involving thousands of people who bought funeral-related cover through credit unions in Scotland and northern England raises important questions about the security of these arrangements, the responsibilities of the companies selling them and whether customers fully understand what they are buying.
The case also provides a timely opportunity to look at the funeral plans currently being advertised and what safeguards customers should expect.
Thousands discover their cover has disappeared
The latest case involves the Family Protection Plan, which was offered through credit unions from 1999.
Around 5,000 people across the UK were left without cover when the scheme ended in November 2025. A coalition of 17 credit unions is now seeking compensation for affected members.
One of the most striking cases reported by BBC Scotland concerns George Davies, aged 82, who had paid premiums for 17 years. He believed he had made provision for his funeral and that his wife would not be left with the financial burden.
However, the policy was cancelled and he is now entitled to nothing.
The Family Protection Plan was arranged through insurance intermediary CMutual, formerly known as CUNA Mutual Group. The insurance was underwritten by Maiden Life, which decided to withdraw from the UK market.
The crucial detail is that this was not technically a conventional prepaid funeral plan. It was renewable life insurance which paid a cash benefit when an insured person died. The premiums did not accumulate in a savings account.
Nevertheless, the product had been marketed and used by many people to provide money towards funeral expenses.
The distinction may be important legally, but it does little to lessen the disappointment of people who believed they had been making long-term provision.
Some credit unions say they cannot afford to meet the claims themselves. One estimates that paying out all the potential benefits to its members could cost £1.3 million, threatening its continued existence.
The credit unions argue that responsibility should be shared between the insurer, the intermediary and the organisations involved in distributing the product.
That is a reasonable argument for the Government and financial regulators to examine. Customers should not automatically be expected to understand the complicated arrangements between insurers, brokers and distributors.
Are today's funeral plans better protected?
There has been an important change in the industry.
Since 29 July 2022, prepaid funeral plans have been regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA).
This followed concerns about poor-value products, high-pressure selling, excessive commissions, unclear exclusions and inadequate financial arrangements to protect customers' money.
Under the new arrangements, providers must be authorised by the FCA. Money paid into a plan must be properly protected, normally through a trust or an insurance arrangement.
Customers also have access to the Financial Ombudsman Service if they have a qualifying complaint.
Importantly, the Financial Services Compensation Scheme (FSCS) provides protection of up to £85,000 per eligible person, per firm, if an authorised funeral plan provider fails.
Where possible, the FSCS will arrange for an equivalent plan with another provider. Alternatively, compensation may be available.
This is a substantial improvement on the situation experienced by the credit union members.
However, regulation does not mean that every funeral plan is necessarily good value, suitable for every customer or identical in what it provides.
Nor does it mean that every product advertised as helping with funeral costs falls within the same regulatory arrangements.
What about the funeral plans advertised on television?
Anyone watching daytime television will probably have seen advertisements offering to arrange funeral expenses in advance.
Some advertise a fixed price, others offer monthly payments, while others concentrate on the apparent savings compared with the cost of a traditional funeral.
There is nothing inherently wrong with these products. In fact, a properly structured prepaid funeral plan can provide reassurance and help families avoid some unexpected costs.
But there are several points worth examining.
First, what exactly is included?
A particularly interesting development concerns direct cremation plans. These can be considerably cheaper than a conventional funeral because there is no attended service or ceremony at the crematorium.
However, not everybody understands this distinction.
In July 2026, the Advertising Standards Authority upheld complaints about television advertisements for Simplicity Cremations, a Dignity Funerals brand. The adverts promoted a low-cost funeral plan without making sufficiently clear that the product was for a non-attended cremation.
The ASA ruled that this was important information which should have been made clear in the advertisements themselves, rather than left for viewers to discover on a website.
A separate ruling in June 2026 also concerned a Pure Cremation television advertisement which could give viewers the impression that an attended service was included.
These cases demonstrate why the small print matters. A plan costing considerably less may be perfectly suitable for somebody who wants a simple direct cremation, but it is not necessarily comparable with a traditional funeral attended by family and friends.
Second, customers should examine what happens if they choose to pay monthly rather than making a single payment.
Instalment arrangements can be more expensive. MoneyHelper estimates that paying by instalments can add between 15% and 26% to the overall cost through interest and administration charges.
There can also be important differences in what happens if the customer dies before completing the payments. Some arrangements guarantee the funeral after a specified period, while others may simply return the premiums paid.
Third, what happens if somebody changes their mind?
Cancellation charges can be significant, and customers may receive considerably less than they have paid in. Some plans allow the money to remain as a contribution towards a funeral rather than providing a full refund.
These are not necessarily reasons to avoid funeral plans, but they are reasons to read the contract carefully.
Another potential confusion: funeral plans and over-50s insurance
There is another distinction worth making.
Some television advertisements promote over-50s life insurance rather than prepaid funeral plans.
These policies generally provide a fixed cash payment when the insured person dies. The money can be used for funeral expenses, but the insurance company does not necessarily arrange or guarantee the funeral itself.
There can be important disadvantages.
For example, somebody paying monthly premiums for many years might eventually pay more into the policy than their family receives when they die.
If they stop paying, they may lose the cover and the premiums already paid.
There may also be restrictions on the amount payable during an initial qualifying period.
Consequently, customers should not assume that an over-50s insurance policy is equivalent to a prepaid funeral plan simply because the television advertisement suggests that it can help pay for a funeral.
What should customers check before signing?
There are some straightforward precautions which could prevent considerable disappointment.
Check that the actual funeral plan provider, not simply the company advertising or selling the product, is authorised by the Financial Conduct Authority.
Ask for a written explanation of precisely what is included. Does it cover a burial, cremation, funeral director's services, coffin, transport and the crematorium or burial fees? Is there an attended service?
Find out whether the price is guaranteed and whether there are additional costs that might fall to the family.
If paying monthly, establish the total amount payable, the length of the payment period and what happens if the customer dies before completing it.
Check the cancellation arrangements and what happens if the nominated funeral director goes out of business.
Finally, make sure that relatives know a plan exists and where the paperwork is kept. A funeral plan which the family cannot find may create unnecessary complications.
A question of trust and accountability
The credit union case should not be dismissed as an unfortunate isolated incident involving an unusual insurance product.
It illustrates how easily customers can misunderstand the difference between insurance, savings and a prepaid service.
The people affected believed they were making responsible provision for their families. Many had paid premiums for years, and some were now too old or unwell to obtain affordable replacement cover.
Although the legal position may be complicated, there is a strong moral argument that the companies involved should consider financial redress, particularly for the most vulnerable customers.
The FCA also needs to consider whether the lessons from this case have been fully incorporated into the regulation of other products sold to people who are trying to prepare for later life.
The newer funeral-plan regulations provide considerably better protection, and that should be acknowledged. But regulation cannot remove every risk, nor can it guarantee that customers will always get the product they think they are buying.
There is a wider lesson here for financial services advertising. When a product is aimed particularly at older people and deals with something as sensitive as death and funeral expenses, clarity should be paramount.
The question is not simply whether a company has complied with the technical requirements of its contract. It is whether an ordinary customer can understand what they are buying, what they will receive and what could happen if circumstances change.
People making provision for their own funerals are trying to do something responsible for their families. They deserve products that are transparent, fairly priced and genuinely dependable.