Brexit: Did Britain Ever Really Understand What It Was Giving Up?

Submitted by Bill Fernie

22nd November 2026

The debate about Britain's relationship with Europe is beginning to change. The Government is seeking closer cooperation with the European Union, negotiating new agreements and reopening opportunities that disappeared when the UK left.

Yet there is a question that deserves rather more attention than it has received: did the British public ever really understand what EU membership provided, and therefore what the country was giving up when it voted to leave?

The referendum took place in June 2016. It was one of the most important political decisions in modern British history, affecting trade, employment, education, farming, fishing, travel, research and Britain's place in the world.

Yet much of the debate concentrated on immigration, sovereignty, the money sent to Brussels and the ability to make our own laws. These were legitimate subjects for discussion, but they represented only part of the relationship.

I remember asking people whether they had heard of the Erasmus programme. It was surprising how often the answer was no. Erasmus gave students opportunities to study and gain experience in other European countries, helping them develop skills, friendships and international connections. Many people who could have benefited from it had little idea that it existed.

It was a small example of a much larger problem. The EU had become involved in so many aspects of everyday life that many of its benefits were almost invisible.

A referendum without enough understanding?
There is evidence that public understanding was limited during the campaign.

Research by the Electoral Reform Society found that only 16% of people described themselves as well or very well informed about the referendum at the beginning of the campaign in February 2016. Even in the final week, that figure had risen to only around 31–33%, depending on the survey measure.

The organisation also noted a remarkable development on the morning after the referendum. Google searches for "What is the EU?" increased dramatically.

That does not prove that people voted without understanding their decision. Nor does it mean that everyone who voted Leave was uninformed. But it does suggest that there was a significant gap between the importance of the decision and the public's knowledge of the institution being discussed.

The Electoral Commission's own research found that 62% believed they had enough information to make an informed decision, while 28% disagreed. These findings illustrate that people had different experiences of the campaign. Access to information was not necessarily the same as understanding the complicated arrangements behind membership.

The question is why governments over several decades had not done more to explain what membership actually meant.

Farming: the importance of European support

Perhaps nowhere was the complexity of EU membership more apparent than in agriculture.

The Common Agricultural Policy (CAP) had been supporting European farmers since the early 1960s. It provided direct payments, rural development funding and measures designed to stabilise agricultural markets.

In the UK, this was particularly important. Parliamentary research estimated that EU agricultural support accounted for around 50–60% of farm incomes in the years before the referendum.

For many farmers, these payments were not simply a bonus. They were an important part of keeping farms financially viable, particularly in less productive areas.

In Scotland, where farming conditions vary considerably between the Borders, the north-east and the Highlands and Islands, the distribution of agricultural support has always been a significant issue.

Leaving the EU offered an opportunity to design a different system, and there were legitimate arguments that the old arrangements needed reform. But it also meant replacing an established system with domestic policies, budgets and administrative arrangements.

The question voters should have been able to consider was not simply whether Britain wanted to leave European agricultural policy, but what would replace it and how much that replacement would cost.

Fishing: more complicated than taking back control

Fishing became one of the most prominent symbols of the Brexit campaign.

The Common Fisheries Policy was unpopular with many British fishermen, particularly those who believed that access to fishing grounds and the distribution of quotas disadvantaged the UK fleet.

The promise of taking back control of British waters was therefore an attractive political message.

But fishing was never just about who could catch fish. It was also about quotas, conservation, shared fish stocks and access to markets.

British fishermen sell substantial quantities of their catch overseas, particularly to European customers. Fresh seafood is perishable, and delays or additional paperwork can be expensive.

The UK-EU Trade and Cooperation Agreement provided tariff-free trade in goods, but did not eliminate border formalities. Seafood exporters faced additional certification and inspection requirements.

There was a trade-off that deserved much more attention during the referendum: gaining greater control over fishing waters did not automatically guarantee better commercial opportunities for fishermen.

Indeed, the two objectives could sometimes conflict.

Regional development: what happened to the money?
Another relatively unfamiliar part of EU membership was regional development funding.

European structural funds helped finance regeneration, business development, training, infrastructure and employment programmes.

These were particularly important in areas that had struggled to attract private investment.

The UK was a net contributor to the EU budget, and it was entirely reasonable to question whether the country received sufficient value for its contributions.

However, it was equally important to explain where the money coming back was going.

A House of Commons Library briefing published in 2017 estimated that the UK received approximately £6 billion annually through various EU funding programmes. Agricultural support accounted for much of this, with regional development and research also receiving substantial sums.

The funding was not free, but neither was it meaningless. It supported projects in communities that might otherwise have struggled to secure investment.

For places such as Caithness and Sutherland, the wider principle of regional funding is particularly relevant. Rural areas often need investment that cannot be justified purely by commercial returns.

Science, universities and international cooperation

The loss of opportunities for scientific cooperation was another issue that received relatively little attention during the referendum.

European research programmes brought universities, businesses and scientists together to tackle problems that individual countries could not necessarily address as effectively on their own.

British universities were major participants in European research programmes.

There were concerns after Brexit about whether British researchers would continue to have access to these networks and funding opportunities.

The UK has subsequently rejoined Horizon Europe as an associated country, from January 2024. This restored access to the programme under agreed conditions, although Britain is no longer participating as an EU member.

It is another example of an arrangement that had to be negotiated separately after Brexit.

What about ordinary people?

There were also everyday benefits that rarely featured in the public debate.

EU membership provided rights and opportunities to live, work and study across member countries. It supported common consumer protections, employment standards, environmental cooperation and arrangements that made travelling and doing business easier.

Some of these arrangements had their origins in agreements that predated the EU itself, and some could have continued outside membership. It would be wrong to suggest that leaving automatically removed every protection or benefit.

Nevertheless, membership provided a common framework and a degree of influence over how those arrangements developed.

For younger people, the loss of freedom of movement and the departure from Erasmus were particularly significant.

The Erasmus example is worth revisiting because it demonstrates how an opportunity can disappear without many people even realising what has happened.

The UK is now returning to Erasmus+ in 2027. The financial contribution for that year has been negotiated, and participation will cover education, training, youth and sport.

The Brexit reset: rebuilding some of what was lost
The latest developments in the relationship with Europe suggest that both sides recognise the practical advantages of closer cooperation.

The November 2026 UK-EU summit welcomed the conclusion of negotiations on a Youth Experience Scheme. This is intended to allow up to 100,000 young people from each side to spend up to three years in the other territory, subject to agreed conditions.

The two sides are also looking at further cooperation in education and other areas.

These arrangements are not a return to EU membership or the previous freedom of movement system. They are negotiated agreements with specific limits and conditions.

But they demonstrate that the relationship is evolving again.

There is also a wider economic question. Businesses trading with Europe have had to adapt to new customs and regulatory requirements. The European Commission itself acknowledges that leaving the Single Market and Customs Union created barriers to trade and cross-border exchanges that did not previously exist.

The Government's current approach is to reduce some of those barriers through closer alignment and cooperation, while retaining the UK's position outside the EU.

A lesson for future generations

It would be too simplistic to conclude that everything about EU membership was beneficial or that leaving was necessarily the wrong decision for every sector or community.

There were genuine disagreements about democratic accountability, immigration, financial contributions, fishing rights and the ability of Britain to determine its own policies.

Those arguments deserved to be heard.

But there was another side to the debate that never received sufficient attention. The public needed to understand not just what membership cost, but what it delivered, who benefited and what would have to be recreated if Britain left.

Governments that supported remaining had a particular responsibility to explain the practical benefits rather than relying on general warnings about economic consequences.

The Leave campaign also had a responsibility to explain how the complex arrangements supporting British businesses, farmers, universities and communities would work after departure.

Neither side could reasonably claim that the public was given a complete picture.

Perhaps the greatest lesson is that major constitutional decisions should never be reduced to a handful of slogans.

The EU was not perfect, and Britain was entitled to question its membership. But before making such a fundamental decision, people needed to understand the institution, its advantages, its disadvantages and the alternatives.

Ten years on, as politicians work to rebuild parts of the relationship, perhaps we should finally have the debate that was missing in 2016: what exactly did Europe provide for Britain, what have we lost, and which parts of that relationship are worth recovering?