Police Legal Bill For Abandoned Cyber Kiosks Could Rise Further
25th February 2019
The cost of Police Scotland's junked phone hacking kiosks is likely to rise again as the force considers taking legal action to prove it did not breach privacy laws.
It spent £370,684 last April on 41 of its cyber kiosks, which let officers copy data from mobile phones, but the plans were shelved following an outcry from privacy campaigners, The Times reports.
The single force sought legal guidance from the Crown Office in October last year but received none. It paid a further £316,678 to Cellebrite, an Israeli manufacturer, to licence the devices for four years.
On 30 January, COPFS wrote to Police Scotland to say that there has been a ‘misunderstanding' by the force, which thought that the request for legal advice had been passed to Crown counsel for consideration.
In the letter, COPFS warned that it would be "inappropriate" for them to comment on a request for broad guidance on police powers as they only give advice on admissibility of evidence into court on a case by case basis.
Upon receiving this from COPFS, Police Scotland wrote to the Scottish Parliament's Justice Sub-Committee on Policing, stating that it believes "the [COPFS] position outlined within to be supportive of the Police Scotland position with regard the existence of a legal basis for the examination of digital device using Cyber Kiosks".
Steve Johnson, assistant chief constable, told the committee: "Police Scotland has continued to retain a high level of confidence on the legal basis to support the proposed use of digital triage devices as part of our cyberforensic capabilities. We do not believe the position described by Crown necessarily contradicts our understanding of the legal basis.
“I have referred this updated position to our internal legal advisors for further consideration, which may include a proposal to seek further independent legal advice on this important matter."
Matthew Rice, Scotland director of the Open Rights Group, said: “They should not be spending more money on receiving more legal advice until all available advice is made available publicly.
“Police Scotland can’t keep rolling the legal advice dice until they get the response they are after. Crown Office have responded and not given them clarity. It is time now for the legal services advice to be released.”
Source Scottish Legal News - www.scottishlegal.com
Related Businesses
Related Articles
A report by the police to the Caithness area committee on 11 November will allow councillors to discuss a range of issues. Chief Inspector Calum Smith - Area Commander (North Highland Area Command) sets out the crime related figures up to June 2024.
A reduction in police activity targeting the most common causes of fatal crashes has been identified as a key factor affecting Police Scotland's ability to keep people safe on the nation's roads. A new report by His Majesty's Inspectorate of Constabulary in Scotland notes that since 2020 the total number of people killed or injured on Scotland’s roads has increased each year.
Police Scotland's North Safety Camera Unit are now operating average speed cameras on the A836 between Reay and Thurso with offences being progressed from Monday 2nd September. In partnership with the Scottish Safety Camera Programme and the Highland Council, the location was identified as having speed concerns and increased traffic volumes, both of which are potential ongoing road safety challenges.
Consider carefully what you are putting on social media, especially if you are staying away to visit friends and relatives this Christmas. Be wary of posting photographs of Christmas parties that contain images of high value jewellery.
Would you like to join the Police? Would you like to live and work in the Caithness area? Police Scotland is actively recruiting good quality and eligible candidates specifically for the Caithness area. We are taking applications now for Police Constable / Special Constable Entry for future intakes during 2023/2024.
UNISON, the union for police staff, says Scotland's police budget cut will see even more crime going unreported and crimes not being fully investigated. The union says around 230 police staff could be cut, including fingerprint examiners, forensic examiners, 999 call handlers, custody staff, high-speed driving instructors, cybercrime experts, payroll, HR and IT staff.
The new Highland and Islands divisional commander will take up post having been sworn in as a Police Scotland officer. Chief Constable Sir Iain Livingstone welcomed and thanked Chief Superintendent Rob Shepherd during a ceremony at Police Scotland Headquarters, Tulliallan, on Monday, 16 January 2023, overseen by Justice of the Peace Gillian Thomson.
Gross misconduct proceedings against police officers should be allowed to continue after they resign from the force to promote transparency and maintain public confidence, according to a public consultation. The move, which would see proceedings continue even if an officer leaves during the course of an investigation into their conduct, was among the recommendations of Dame Elish Angiolini's independent review into how police complaints and allegations of misconduct should be handled.
The total number of people proceeded against in Scottish courts fell by 46% to 46,497 in the year to 2020-21, according to National Statistics published by Scotland's Chief Statistician today. The number of people convicted fell at a similar rate, down 44% to 42,532.
Cllr Matthew Reiss, Highland Council's Strategic Lead for Police and Fire has welcomed Police Scotland's announcement that it has created fifteen new posts to further enhance the development of call handling services, based in Inverness. He said: "We were delighted in October last year to welcome 25 new jobs in Inverness with the creation of a specialist call handling service team and these fifteen additional new posts based in the Highlands are great news.
