The Big Green Challenge

11th October 2008

a talking point for teenagers in the Highlands and Islands

An innovative project by Highlands and Islands Enterprise (HIE) is helping pupils across Scotland to gain a better understanding and awareness of renewable energy.

More than 120 S1 & S3 students from 25 schools across the Highlands and Islands are putting their talking skills to the test in The Big Green Challenge debating competition. They have been working alongside local mentors to research both sides of the renewables debate.

The first rounds of the competition are taking place throughout October, with pupils from schools in the Western Isles and Shetland to Tiree and Arran participating in live debates.

The Big Green Challenge is a HIE initiative which is aimed at increasing awareness and understanding of renewable energy. HIE recognises renewable energy as a sector with high growth potential which will benefit the local economy and communities across the region. Increasing Scotland's renewable energy generation is also a key Scottish Government pledge, with the aim of half of Scotland's electricity to come from renewable sources by 2020. More than 120 pupils from 25 schools, fielding 43 teams have been working alongside local mentors to research both sides of the renewables debate in preparation for the first round competition.

Dr John McClatchey of the Environmental Research Institute (ERI) who has been involved in mentoring participating teams said: "It was really good to work with the enthusiastic pupils who were being challenged to think deeply about the benefits and problems of renewable energy that I and my colleagues are researching at ERI. The debate will help them to build on their knowledge of science, geography and politics, and bring it all together to understand the issues. It will also develop their speaking and presentational skills (from their work in English and Drama) in order to make their case. It should prove to be a really beneficial experience for everyone involved."

Support for the pupils has come from The Big Green Challenge portal website www.thebiggreenchallenge.co.uk which also has pages in Gaelic. Participating schools have also had access to top tips for debating to hone their skills and have had sessions with mentors on presentation. The Big Green Challenge participants are expected to comprehensively research motions both for and against renewable energy.

Anna Allan, senior development manager in HIE's Energy team says, "The Highlands and Islands not only has some of the best renewable energy resources in Europe, but also some of the most diverse, in what is a relatively small geographic area. It's vital that we help support understanding of both sides of the renewables debate and that we encourage our young people to be well informed and engaged citizens.

"There is a desire to build a diverse renewable energy sector in the Highlands and Islands, and it's the young people in our schools today who will drive this industry forward. The Big Green Challenge is about engaging with young people and ensuring they can see both sides of the renewables debate."

Teams from Gairloch High in Gairloch, Speyside High in Aberlour, Alness Academy in Alness, Portree High School in Skye and Shetland based Sandwick Junior High won their rounds this week. Three further local heats will take place after the October holidays, and the eight winners from this stage will progress to the semi-final in November. Four teams will then go forward to the grand final in January 2009, when they will compete for a group trip to Iceland to visit the country's famous Blue Lagoon waterfall and the geothermal area of Geysir.

A spokesperson for Comhairle nan Eilean Siar said: "This is an excellent initiative for the school participants. The Western Isles has tremendous resources of renewable energy and a unique environment so it should be a challenging debate! The competition at the Nicolson Institute featured schools from Gairloch, Lionel, Shawbost and the Nicolson who all worked exceptionally hard to prepare for what was an interesting and informative event."

Donnie MacDonald, Highland Council's Head of Education Services said: "Within Curriculum for Excellence we are keen that learners explore and engage with contemporary issues which give a real context for their studies in the sciences and in engineering. There are also related ethical and sustainability issues which the young people involved will explore through discussion and debate with pupils across the Highlands and Islands."

For further information on the Big Green Challenge log onto
www.thebiggreenchallenge.co.uk

 

Related Businesses

 

Related Articles

Yesterday : Advisory / Counseling Services

Scotland Had Its Own Skills Review Three Years Ago. So Why Are We Still Discussing the Same Problems?

Alan Milburn's new report on young people not in education, employment or training raises an uncomfortable question for Scotland.  Much of what he recommends was already identified in a major Scottish Government-commissioned review by James Withers in 2023.  

Yesterday : Advisory / Counseling Services

Government must match Milburn’s ambition to properly invest in young people

Recommendations tackle inadequacies in health, education and employment support, and improve incentives to work, but retains low level of unemployment benefit.   Alan Milburn’s Review has set out the right scale of ambition needed to tackle Britain’s NEET crisis, with bold investment in services and benefit reforms that rightly aim to end Britain’s damaging ‘left alone’ culture.  

Yesterday : Advisory / Counseling Services

Alan Milburn Calls for a Complete Overhaul of How We Support Young People As His Report Published

Alan Milburn has been appointed as the Chair of the new Youth Opportunities Unit.   The new Unit will sit at the centre of government, reporting directly to the Prime Minister, driving the cross-system changes needed to deliver greater opportunities and support for young people.  

16/11/2026 : Advisory / Counseling Services

The People Building Caithness's Future: Meet the Local Entrepreneurs Making Things Happen

When people discuss the future of Caithness, attention often turns to major employers, government investment, renewable energy developments and the search for new industries.   All of these matter.  

31/10/2026 : Local Authority

Caithness at the Sharp End: Broadband, Buses and Public Services Under Pressure

From the loss of a direct bus link to Inverness to uncertainty over rural broadband, a difficult council budget and the future of community organisations, the past week has provided plenty for Caithness residents to think about.  But there have also been celebrations, local achievements and signs of community spirit.  

31/10/2026 : Advisory / Counseling Services

The North Sea's Changing Future: What Does It Mean for Jobs and Investment in Caithness?

The future of the North Sea energy industry is once again attracting considerable attention.  With the UK Government facing difficult decisions about oil and gas production, energy security, investment and the transition towards renewable energy.  

23/10/2026 : Marine Services

HIE funding supports new strategy role at Wick Harbour

Wick Harbour Authority (WHA) is to appoint a new strategy manager after securing up to £52,500 from Highlands and Islands Enterprise (HIE) to help fund the post.   The post holder will help WHA deliver its emerging harbour masterplan and outline business case, strengthen capacity and develop new business opportunities.  

20/10/2026 : Advisory / Counseling Services

 
HIE welcomes £350m cable factory opening

The official opening of the UK’s first HVDC subsea cable factory, located at the Port of Nigg in Easter Ross, has been welcomed by Highlands and Islands Enterprise (HIE).   The facility represents an investment of £350m.  

17/10/2026 : Advisory / Counseling Services

When Community Ownership Isn't Enough: The Uncertain Future of GlenWyvis Distillery

The Highland distillery was built with the support of thousands of people who wanted to create something lasting for their community.  Its entry into administration exposes the financial risks facing ambitious local ventures, even when the original idea has widespread public support.  

8/10/2026 : Advisory / Counseling Services

Innovation and AI: New opportunities for businesses across the Highlands and Islands

Innovation has always been a defining characteristic of businesses and social enterprises in the Highlands and Islands.   Whether developing new products, finding ways to overcome the challenges of distance and geography, improving services, or identifying new markets, organisations across the region have a long track record of adapting and evolving.