When Fuel Prices Rise, Who Pays the Bill for Public Services?

28th October 2026

Councils, the NHS and other public bodies face a difficult choice when rising diesel and energy costs threaten the contractors they depend on. School transport in rural Scotland illustrates the problem.

When fuel prices rise sharply, the effects reach much further than the forecourt. Businesses face higher operating costs, household budgets come under pressure and public bodies can find themselves paying more to deliver services for which budgets were agreed months or even years earlier.

For councils and the NHS, the problem is particularly awkward. Many essential services are delivered by private companies, charities and small local operators working under contracts that specify what they will be paid. If fuel and energy costs rise unexpectedly, the contractor may find that the agreed price no longer covers the cost of doing the job.

The question then becomes a difficult one: should the public body pay more, should the contractor absorb the increase, or should the service be reduced or withdrawn?

School transport provides a clear example

School transport is particularly vulnerable to increases in diesel prices. A coach or minibus operator may have agreed to transport pupils for a fixed annual payment, based on the fuel prices, wages, maintenance costs and other expenses prevailing when the contract was awarded.

If diesel becomes substantially more expensive, the operator's costs rise every time the vehicle leaves the depot. On a long rural route, where buses may travel considerable distances to collect relatively small numbers of pupils, the extra expense can be significant.

In urban areas, operators may have more opportunities to use vehicles on several routes throughout the day. In Caithness and Sutherland, long distances between settlements and schools can make that more difficult.

A small operator may have only a handful of vehicles. It cannot necessarily spread the additional costs across a large fleet or other profitable activities. Nor can it simply increase fares to parents when the council is paying for the contracted service.

The Confederation of Passenger Transport warned in June 2026 that rising diesel costs were putting school transport contracts at risk. Its survey found that 38% of responding operators were likely to have to hand back school transport contracts because of rising costs. This was a warning from surveyed operators, rather than evidence that all those contracts had actually been withdrawn.

The implications are serious. If an operator walks away from a contract, the council may have to find a replacement at short notice, negotiate a higher price or make alternative arrangements. In a rural area with few transport providers, finding another company with the right vehicles and available drivers may be difficult.

The cheapest tender is of little value if the operator cannot afford to complete the contract.

Should councils share the additional costs?

There is evidence that some councils are considering ways to address the problem rather than leaving operators to bear every increase.

Dumfries and Galloway Council considered a fuel-cost risk-sharing arrangement in June 2026. Under the proposed model, transport providers would absorb increases up to 30% above August 2025 fuel-price levels, with the council meeting additional fuel costs above that threshold for specified contracts. The estimated annual cost was £110,000 at the prevailing prices.

This approach recognises that contractors should normally manage ordinary fluctuations in their costs. However, an exceptional increase can undermine the assumptions on which a contract was originally priced.

A risk-sharing arrangement can offer a compromise. The operator remains responsible for routine commercial risks, while the council helps with costs that rise beyond an agreed threshold.

Such arrangements need safeguards. Contractors should provide evidence of their actual fuel expenditure, support should be restricted to eligible contracts, and any payments should reflect genuine additional costs. If fuel prices subsequently fall, the adjustment should be capable of working in reverse.

There is also a question of fairness. A company that submitted an unrealistically low tender should not automatically be rescued at public expense. Equally, a responsible operator should not necessarily be expected to absorb an exceptional and sustained increase that makes an essential service uneconomic.

The NHS and social care face similar pressures

The issue extends well beyond school buses.

Community nurses, health visitors and other NHS staff may need to travel considerable distances to visit patients. When staff use their own vehicles, rising petrol and diesel costs can make those journeys more expensive, particularly if mileage allowances do not keep pace.

The same problem affects care-at-home services. A care worker may spend a substantial part of the working day travelling between clients, especially in rural communities. Higher fuel costs can erode the margin available to a provider that has already agreed prices for delivering care.

These are not simply questions about business profits. If a provider cannot recruit staff, cover travel costs or maintain its services, vulnerable people may struggle to receive the support they need.

Public bodies must also consider the wider network of contractors responsible for building maintenance, waste collection, deliveries, repairs and other services. Fuel is only one part of their costs, but it can be an important one when margins are tight.

Energy contracts present a different problem

Electricity and gas create a related, but different, challenge.

A public body that has agreed a fixed-price energy contract will not normally be able to change the price simply because wholesale energy costs have risen. That is part of the bargain: the contract protects the buyer against sudden increases, but may also prevent it from immediately benefiting when prices fall.

When contracts expire, however, the cost of renewing them can be considerably higher or lower than expected. Councils, hospitals and other public institutions must then find room in their budgets to pay the new price or reduce consumption.

They can improve insulation, invest in more efficient equipment, review heating arrangements and negotiate better purchasing terms where possible. But these measures take time and may require money upfront.

A hospital cannot simply turn off essential equipment, and a school cannot operate safely without adequate heating. There are limits to how much energy consumption can be reduced without affecting services.

The pressure on public budgets

Councils and NHS boards already face competing demands for money. Higher payments to transport providers and other contractors may mean less funding available for other services unless additional resources are provided.

The financial pressure can therefore spread. A council that pays more for school transport may have less available for road repairs or other local services. An NHS board facing higher energy and transport bills may find it harder to accommodate other cost increases.

Yet refusing every request for additional funding carries its own risks. If contractors withdraw, the public body may have to arrange emergency cover, pay more to a replacement provider or accept disruption.

The answer cannot be to renegotiate every contract whenever costs rise. Nor is it sensible to assume that every contract can be delivered at its original price regardless of what happens to fuel and energy markets.

Public bodies need to distinguish between ordinary fluctuations that contractors should manage and exceptional increases that threaten the continuation of essential services.

Why rural Scotland deserves particular attention

For Caithness and Sutherland, these issues have a distinctive importance. Long journeys, scattered settlements and a limited pool of transport operators can make services more expensive to deliver and harder to replace when a contractor withdraws.

A school transport contract that appears affordable on paper may become difficult to sustain if diesel prices rise sharply. A small care provider may have few ways to offset higher travel costs. An alternative supplier based far away may itself need to charge more to cover the additional mileage.

That is why contract management matters. Councils should understand how exposed essential services are to fuel-price changes, identify contracts where a failure would cause serious disruption, and establish clear rules for dealing with exceptional increases before a crisis develops.

Future contracts could include transparent fuel-price adjustment mechanisms, periodic reviews or agreed thresholds for sharing exceptional costs. Tender evaluations should also consider whether the proposed price is realistic for the full contract period, rather than focusing exclusively on the lowest initial bid.

A question of value, not just price

There is a legitimate concern that public money must be spent carefully. Contractors should not expect taxpayers to underwrite every commercial risk, and public bodies cannot promise unlimited additional payments.

But there is an equally important consideration: the cost of a service includes the risk of it failing.

When a school bus does not arrive, a care visit is missed or essential maintenance is delayed, the consequences can extend well beyond the original contract price. In remote communities, there may be no convenient alternative.

The challenge for councils, the NHS and other public bodies is to balance financial discipline with practical reality. Contracts need to allocate risks fairly, recognise exceptional circumstances and provide a sensible route for resolving problems before services are lost.

The cheapest contract is not necessarily the best value for taxpayers. It is the contract that delivers a reliable service, at a reasonable price, for the whole period agreed.

 

Related Businesses

 

Related Articles

Yesterday : Local Authority

Inverness and Highland City-Region Deal delivers £412.98 million investment across the region

The Inverness and Highland City-Region Deal has delivered public and private investment across the Highlands totalling £412.98 million, according to its 2025/26 Annual Report, supporting major investments in housing, tourism, innovation, and infrastructure.   Highlights from the 2025/26 Annual Report include the start of the Corran Ferry Infrastructure Improvement project, the completion of 234 affordable homes across Highland communities, and the opening of The Inverness Castle Experience, which has welcomed more than 107,000 paying visitors since opening.  

9/11/2026 : Local Authority

Wind Farms, Councillors and Freedom of Speech: Is Scotland's Planning System Silencing Local Dissent?

The growing number of wind farm developments across the Highlands has created an increasingly difficult question for local democracy.  How far can elected councillors go in expressing concerns about renewable energy developments before they risk being accused of bias and excluded from decisions affecting their own communities? That question has now been brought into sharper focus by Highland councillor Matthew Reiss, who has approached the Ethical Standards Commissioner seeking clear guidance on councillors' conduct when publicly expressing views about renewable energy.  

7/11/2026 : Local Authority

Are Chromebooks Taking Over Our Classrooms? Highland Schools Face Questions About Digital Learning

The use of Chromebooks, laptops and other digital devices in schools was once widely regarded as an important step towards modernising education.  Giving every pupil access to technology promised to improve learning, widen access to information and prepare young people for a world increasingly dependent on digital skills.  

6/11/2026 : Local Authority

Secret HQ Move: Is Highland Council Chasing Savings or Just Shuffling the Deck?

A storm is brewing behind closed doors at Glenurquhart Road.  Recent private discussions have revealed plans for Highland Council to potentially abandon its historic headquarters and relocate to Great Glen House, the current £13 million base of NatureScot.  

5/11/2026 : Local Authority

Committee to consider 1 April 2027 start date for Short-Term Let Control Areas

Members of The Highland Council’s Economy and Infrastructure Committee will be asked to agree that Short Term Let Control Areas (STLCAs) for Inverness City and Highland Rural come into effect from 1 April 2027.   The recommendation to the Committee follows the decision by Scottish Government Ministers on 26 October 2026 to approve designation of the STLCAs, which are an important tool to manage future loss of housing stock, support sustainable communities and balance housing needs with the visitor economy.  Chair of the Council’s Economy and Infrastructure Committee, Cllr Ken Gowans, said: “Following Scottish Government approval, the Council can now move forward with implementing these STLCAs, which will help us strike a better balance between supporting tourism growth and protecting much-needed housing for local people.  

6/11/2026 : Local Authority

Key decisions made to improve Highland Bereavement Services

Members of the Communities and Place Committee have made key decisions that will improve affordability and choice within Highland bereavement services at Inverness Crematorium; and introduce stronger governance and transparency for charitable funding applications through the crematorium metal recycling scheme.   Members also approved the adoption of a standardised burial management plan across Highland which will ensure compliance with new national burial management legislation.  

6/11/2026 : Local Authority

Council-owned D&E Coaches delivers £700k profit while supporting Highland transport

D&E Coaches has recorded a £700,000 profit after tax in its first full year under Highland Council ownership.   The Council purchased the coach and bus operator in March 2025 to support the ongoing provision of sustainable and reliable transport services across the Highlands.  

6/11/2026 : Local Authority

Abandoned Vehicles Policy approved by Highland Councillors

Members of The Highland Council’s Communities and Place Committee have approved a new Policy on Abandoned Vehicles that will provide a framework for investigating, assessing and enforcement against abandoned vehicles across the region.   Chair of Communities and Place, Cllr Graham MacKenzie said: “I welcome this new policy which will help to make a difference in communities where the nuisance of abandoned vehicles arises.  

6/11/2026 : Local Authority

Funding success builds on Highland Council’s commitment to warmer, energy efficient homes

Climate Change Committee Members have welcomed news that The Highland Council has successfully secured external funding in the region of £5.4 million for 2026/27.  This grant funding will support retrofit and decarbonisation programmes for eligible owner occupier, private rented and Council owned houses across the Highlands.  

6/11/2026 : Local Authority

Council to commission independent review of licensing

Members of The Highland Council have today approved the commissioning of an independent external review of the Council’s licensing arrangements following a Council motion approved on 17 September 2026.   The review will consider governance, decision-making processes and opportunities for improvement.