Britain's NEET Crisis: Alan Milburn Calls for a Complete Overhaul of How We Support Young People

17th November 2026

Britain has a growing problem with young people who are neither working nor studying, and a major new review by former Labour Health Secretary Sir Alan Milburn argues that the country needs to rethink its entire approach.

The report, published on 17 November 2026, addresses a problem affecting approximately 981,000 people aged 16 to 24. That is almost one in eight young people, representing a considerable loss of potential for individuals, employers and the wider economy.

The issue is not simply that young people cannot find jobs. Increasing numbers are becoming detached from education, training and the labour market altogether. Milburn believes that the systems designed to help them are fragmented, poorly coordinated and often intervene too late.

His conclusion is that Britain needs a complete system reset.

Bringing services together

One of the most significant recommendations is the creation of a local Youth Opportunity Service.

Rather than expecting young people to navigate separate employment offices, colleges, health services and careers organisations, these services would bring assistance together.

Each young person would have a named adviser and an individual plan, taking account of their circumstances, abilities and aspirations.

This is an important change in approach. Someone struggling with mental health problems, family difficulties or a lack of qualifications may need considerably more than a list of job vacancies.

The review proposes that these services should be established across England by 2029, with local mayors overseeing their development.

A guarantee of opportunities

Milburn also wants an opportunity guarantee for 18 to 24-year-olds, offering a route into employment, education or training.

Where a young person cannot find a job through existing arrangements, the Government would provide a funded six-month employment opportunity.

There would also be more apprenticeships, pre-apprenticeships, vocational courses and supported learning.

This recognises that not everybody is ready to move straight into full-time employment. A few hours of work, practical experience or a training placement could be the beginning of a longer journey.

The report also argues that employers need more encouragement to recruit young people. A proposed £5,000 payment for small businesses taking on a young person is one of the incentives being considered.

That could be particularly important for smaller employers who might otherwise be reluctant to take on someone with little experience.

The controversial benefits proposals

Perhaps the most politically sensitive part of the review concerns the benefits system.

Milburn argues that the existing arrangements are not doing enough to help young people move towards employment where they are capable of doing so.

He proposes a different system of financial support for younger people, with more targeted assistance for those with disabilities and health conditions.

There would be greater emphasis on participation in employment, education, training or volunteering, with sanctions only after repeated attempts to re-engage someone.

However, this raises important questions.

Some young people could receive less financial support under the proposals, particularly those currently receiving health-related benefits.

There is a genuine distinction between someone who has become detached from employment because of a lack of opportunity and someone whose disability or health condition makes working extremely difficult.

A system that encourages participation is worthwhile, but it must not penalise people who genuinely cannot work or who need substantial support before they can consider employment.

The cost of putting things right

The financial commitment is substantial.

Milburn proposes an initial investment of £500 million in 2027–28, eventually rising to around £5.8 billion annually by 2036–37.

He argues that the investment should eventually be offset by lower benefit expenditure, increased employment and higher tax revenues.

The review suggests that the reforms could bring hundreds of thousands more young people into employment and training over the next decade.

However, these are projections rather than guaranteed outcomes. The Government will need to demonstrate that the additional spending produces lasting improvements rather than simply creating another collection of short-lived schemes.

What does this mean for Scotland?

There is an important distinction when considering the recommendations in Scotland.

Employment support and social security involve both UK and Scottish responsibilities, while education, colleges, apprenticeships and many aspects of skills policy are devolved.

Consequently, a Youth Opportunity Service designed around English mayors and local government arrangements cannot simply be copied into Scotland.

But the underlying problems are familiar.

Young people in places such as Caithness and Sutherland can face additional barriers. There may be fewer employers offering entry-level jobs, limited choice of apprenticeships and considerable distances between home, college and employment.

A young person in Wick or Thurso may have the ability and ambition to work but find that the opportunities available locally are limited.

Transport is another consideration. A training place or apprenticeship is of little practical value if someone cannot afford to travel to it or there is no suitable public transport.

Scotland already has colleges, local employability partnerships, Skills Development Scotland and other organisations involved in helping young people. The question is whether these services are sufficiently joined up and whether they have the resources to provide sustained support.

For rural communities, the answer may require more locally tailored arrangements rather than simply expanding existing national programmes.

A problem that starts before unemployment

One of the strongest messages from the Milburn review is that the problem cannot be solved by concentrating solely on young people who are already claiming benefits.

Disengagement can begin much earlier, through poor school attendance, difficulties at home, health problems, a lack of confidence or an education system that fails to recognise different abilities.

By the time someone reaches their early twenties, the difficulties may have become deeply established.

There is also a danger of treating almost one million young people as though they are all in the same situation. Some desperately want work but cannot get an interview. Others need further education, while some face disabilities or health conditions that require specialist assistance.

A single solution will not work for everyone.

Will the Government deliver?

The Milburn review is an ambitious attempt to tackle a problem that has been allowed to grow over many years.

Its strongest recommendation is perhaps not any individual employment scheme but the recognition that education, health, employment and welfare cannot continue operating as disconnected parts of government.

There will be political arguments about the cost, the proposed changes to benefits and the responsibilities placed on employers.

There will also be questions about whether the Government can deliver the necessary changes while public services are already under considerable financial pressure.

But there is a wider economic argument.

Britain needs skilled workers, businesses need new recruits and young people need a realistic opportunity to establish themselves in working life.

Leaving almost one million young people on the sidelines is a waste of talent that the country can ill afford.

The real test will be whether the Government turns the recommendations into practical opportunities that young people can actually access, including those living far from the major cities.