Government must match Milburn’s ambition to properly invest in young people

18th November 2026

Recommendations tackle inadequacies in health, education and employment support, and improve incentives to work, but retains low level of unemployment benefit.

Alan Milburn’s Review has set out the right scale of ambition needed to tackle Britain’s NEET crisis, with bold investment in services and benefit reforms that rightly aim to end Britain’s damaging ‘left alone’ culture.

However, if more young people are to be supported only by unemployment benefit which provides less than £80 a week, then its inadequacy will also need to be addressed, the Resolution Foundation said on Tuesday.

With around one million young people in Britain currently not in education, employment or training – and a 13.6 per cent 15-24 NEET rate in 2025 that was more than 2.5 times as high as the Netherlands (4.8 per cent) – the crisis that Alan Milburn’s review has been tasked with solving is huge.

The recommendations of the final report have risen to the scale of that challenge, setting out a comprehensive plan to invest in young people’s futures through mental health support in childhood, better funded educational pathways, more training opportunities and more personalised employment support. This is the right approach given that among the 23 OECD countries with a lower NEET rate than the UK, all but two achieve this entirely by having more young people participating in education or combining education and work.

The most controversial part of the review relates to welfare reform, where there will be winners and losers from replacing Universal Credit (UC) with a new Youth Allowance.

Winners could include those already in work, or able to newly access work, who would gain from a proposed new work allowance for young people. Added to this, the one-in-three young people in receipt of UC that do not live with their parents will gain £20 a week if their standard benefit rate is increased to match the rate for those aged 25 and over, as the report suggests it may.

The clear losers would include those unable to work due to a health condition, even after extensive support, and whose cash entitlements are reduced. They will lose entitlement to the health element of UC worth £2,600 a year for new claimants. Currently 176,000 young people (aged 16-24) receive this, including 110,000 who also receive Personal Independence Payment (PIP). Overall, 450,000 young people get PIP, which is on average worth around £8,400 a year.

The UK has seen a faster rate of convergence of rising ill-health into labour market inactivity than other countries, and reforming the system to increase both support and conditionality is important to tackling this trend.

Those who do, nevertheless, experience a period out of work would be left on a system that provides a very low level of income. Two-in-three 16-24-year olds in receipt of UC live with their parents and would still only be entitled to support that is worth less than £80 a week – 20 per cent lower than it is for those aged 25 and over, and equivalent to just 18 per cent of full-time minimum wage earnings.

The proposed reforms to PIP have some attractive principles: linking the cash awards more closely to extra costs faced and considering when local services could provide support more effectively. Such a system should also not be driven solely by consideration of NEETs though given that almost two-thirds of young people in receipt of PIP are currently in work or education. Added to this, the conditions, costs and challenges faced by young people are not entirely different from those of older claimants. The Government should determine, following the Timms review, an appropriate disability benefit system and then apply it to all ages.

Ruth Curtice, Chief Executive of the Resolution Foundation, said:

“Over the course of his review, Alan Milburn has made plain the scale of the challenge Britain faces in providing enough education, employment, and training opportunities for young people. The recommendations he has set out today rise to that challenge.

“The proposed welfare reforms are likely to be the most contested aspect of this review even though they’ll play a relatively small role in tackling Britain’s NEET crisis. The biggest winners may well be those already in work, while those with health conditions who struggle to work could lose out.

“The move away from a ‘left alone’ approach to welfare is welcome, though the overall benefit savings of £3.6 billion by 2036-37 that Milburn says his programme would achieve suggest that some young people – likely those whose health or disability prevents them from working – could be considerably worse off.

“The Government must match Alan Milburn’s ambition next year with a bold White Paper and a Spending Review that has investment in young people at its heart.”