Scotland Had Its Own Skills Review Three Years Ago. So Why Are We Still Discussing the Same Problems?

18th November 2026

Alan Milburn's new report on young people not in education, employment or training raises an uncomfortable question for Scotland. Much of what he recommends was already identified in a major Scottish Government-commissioned review by James Withers in 2023. What has happened to those recommendations, and why has progress been so slow?

The publication of Alan Milburn's report on young people not in education, employment or training (NEET) has brought renewed attention to a problem affecting almost a million young people across the UK.

His report, From a Welfare State to a Working State: A New Settlement for the Next Generation, argues that the existing approach is failing too many young people. Rather than waiting until someone has become detached from education and employment, government should intervene earlier, provide individual support and create realistic routes into work, training or further education.

There is much to consider in his recommendations. However, Scotland should not be starting this discussion from scratch.

In June 2023, the Scottish Government published an independent review by James Withers entitled Fit for the Future: Developing a Post-School Learning System to Fuel Economic Transformation.

Withers, who had considerable experience of business and industry, was asked to examine how Scotland's skills system was organised and how it could better meet the needs of employers, learners and the economy.

His report contained 15 recommendations, including five major structural changes. At its heart was a straightforward diagnosis: Scotland had a fragmented and unnecessarily complicated system, with too many organisations and overlapping responsibilities.

The similarities with Milburn's latest findings are striking.

Two reports, much common ground

Both reviews recognise that young people need better routes from school into employment and that the education and training system must be more closely connected to the requirements of employers.

Both place considerable importance on vocational education, apprenticeships and further education. There is also agreement that responsibility should be clearer, that training should reflect local economic needs and that employers must have a stronger voice.

However, there are differences.

Withers concentrated primarily on the machinery of Scotland's post-school education and skills system. He wanted to simplify the organisations responsible for funding, planning and delivering training.

Milburn takes a wider approach. His concern is not simply whether the right courses exist, but what happens to young people who become disconnected from education, employment and society.

He proposes an Opportunity Guarantee and a Support Guarantee for young people aged 18 to 24. These would provide a route into education, apprenticeships, training, work experience or employment, alongside help with barriers such as mental health, disability, housing and transport.

He also proposes a locally delivered Youth Opportunity Service, with a named adviser and an individual plan for each young person.

In that sense, Milburn is addressing the consequences of a system failing individuals, while Withers was looking at how the institutions behind that system should be reorganised.

What happened to the Withers recommendations?

This is where the comparison becomes particularly interesting.

The Scottish Government did not simply put the Withers report on a shelf. It established a Post-School Education and Skills Reform Programme and began work on changing the responsibilities of the organisations involved.

A significant development has been legislation to simplify the funding and governance arrangements.

The Tertiary Education and Training legislation passed in 2026 provides for the Scottish Funding Council to take on responsibility for funding national training programmes and all apprenticeships, alongside a redesigned role for the organisation.

The Scottish Government has also been working on a new approach to skills planning, involving the Scottish Funding Council and Skills Development Scotland.

These are important steps towards the structural changes Withers proposed.

But there is a considerable difference between passing legislation, reorganising public bodies and actually improving the opportunities available to young people.

An especially revealing assessment came from Audit Scotland in June 2026.

Its report on post-school education and skills reform found that progress had been slow and that the Scottish Government still lacked a sufficiently clear delivery plan.

It highlighted weaknesses in governance, insufficient resources, uncertainty about costs and benefits, and a lack of clarity about the outcomes expected.

The Auditor General, Stephen Boyle, warned of a concerning gap between government intentions, planning and actual progress.

That is a fairly serious assessment, particularly when the original review was published three years earlier.

There is another revealing point. In evidence to the Scottish Parliament in 2026, James Withers himself said that his formal appointment ended in June 2023 and that he had not subsequently had a formal role in implementing his recommendations or been formally consulted on progress.

It raises questions about how much ownership the Scottish Government has taken of the changes it commissioned him to recommend.

Scotland must look beyond reorganising institutions

There is a danger that governments become absorbed in restructuring organisations, changing reporting arrangements and moving responsibilities between public bodies.

These changes may be necessary, but they do not automatically create jobs, improve training or give a young person a better chance of finding a worthwhile career.

For example, a young person in Caithness may face very different challenges from someone living in Glasgow or Edinburgh.

There may be fewer employers, a narrower range of vacancies, transport difficulties and limited access to some specialist training. A college course or apprenticeship that works well in a large city may not be readily available in a rural community.

This is why the local dimension of Milburn's proposals deserves attention in Scotland.

Local authorities, colleges, employers, health services and employment support organisations need to work together. Young people should not have to navigate a collection of disconnected public services to find the help they need.

There is also a wider economic issue. Training people for jobs that do not exist locally, or for industries that are not expanding, is unlikely to solve the problem. Skills policy must be linked to economic development and actual employment opportunities.

Will Milburn's recommendations make a difference in Scotland?

There is an important constitutional distinction here.

Milburn's review was commissioned by the UK Government and its proposals will primarily shape policy in England, where employment support and much of the relevant education system are organised differently.

Education and training are largely devolved matters in Scotland. The UK Government has said it will work with the devolved administrations so that young people throughout the UK can benefit from better local support.

But Scotland will need to decide how far it wishes to adopt similar arrangements and how they fit with the reforms already under way.

That creates an opportunity. Scotland does not need to copy every recommendation, but it should examine whether the new proposals offer practical solutions to problems that its own review identified three years ago.

The Scottish Government should also explain what has been achieved through the Withers programme, what remains outstanding and when young people and employers can expect to see tangible improvements.

The real test is what changes for young people

There is no shortage of reports identifying weaknesses in education, training and employment support. There is also no shortage of government announcements promising reform.

The difficulty is turning recommendations into results.

James Withers identified the need for a simpler and more responsive skills system in 2023. Alan Milburn has now highlighted the wider consequences when young people cannot find a route into education or employment.

Both are pointing towards a system that should be more closely connected to employers, local communities and the needs of individual learners.

The Audit Scotland findings suggest that Scotland has some way to go before it can claim that the Withers recommendations have been fully delivered.

Perhaps the most important question is not whether Scotland needs another review, another consultation or another programme of institutional reform.

It is why, three years after commissioning an independent review that identified many of the problems, the Scottish Government is still struggling to demonstrate that its reforms are delivering the improvements that young people need.

Young people cannot afford to wait indefinitely while governments reorganise the organisations that are supposed to help them.

James Withers Report

Summary of Withers Report

Audit Scotland Report June 2026

Millburn Review Final Report 17 N0vember 2026

 

Related Businesses

 

Related Articles

Today : Advisory / Counseling Services

Government must match Milburn’s ambition to properly invest in young people

Recommendations tackle inadequacies in health, education and employment support, and improve incentives to work, but retains low level of unemployment benefit.   Alan Milburn’s Review has set out the right scale of ambition needed to tackle Britain’s NEET crisis, with bold investment in services and benefit reforms that rightly aim to end Britain’s damaging ‘left alone’ culture.  

Today : Advisory / Counseling Services

Alan Milburn Calls for a Complete Overhaul of How We Support Young People As His Report Published

Alan Milburn has been appointed as the Chair of the new Youth Opportunities Unit.   The new Unit will sit at the centre of government, reporting directly to the Prime Minister, driving the cross-system changes needed to deliver greater opportunities and support for young people.  

16/11/2026 : Advisory / Counseling Services

The People Building Caithness's Future: Meet the Local Entrepreneurs Making Things Happen

When people discuss the future of Caithness, attention often turns to major employers, government investment, renewable energy developments and the search for new industries.   All of these matter.  

31/10/2026 : Local Authority

Caithness at the Sharp End: Broadband, Buses and Public Services Under Pressure

From the loss of a direct bus link to Inverness to uncertainty over rural broadband, a difficult council budget and the future of community organisations, the past week has provided plenty for Caithness residents to think about.  But there have also been celebrations, local achievements and signs of community spirit.  

31/10/2026 : Advisory / Counseling Services

The North Sea's Changing Future: What Does It Mean for Jobs and Investment in Caithness?

The future of the North Sea energy industry is once again attracting considerable attention.  With the UK Government facing difficult decisions about oil and gas production, energy security, investment and the transition towards renewable energy.  

23/10/2026 : Marine Services

HIE funding supports new strategy role at Wick Harbour

Wick Harbour Authority (WHA) is to appoint a new strategy manager after securing up to £52,500 from Highlands and Islands Enterprise (HIE) to help fund the post.   The post holder will help WHA deliver its emerging harbour masterplan and outline business case, strengthen capacity and develop new business opportunities.  

20/10/2026 : Advisory / Counseling Services

 
HIE welcomes £350m cable factory opening

The official opening of the UK’s first HVDC subsea cable factory, located at the Port of Nigg in Easter Ross, has been welcomed by Highlands and Islands Enterprise (HIE).   The facility represents an investment of £350m.  

17/10/2026 : Advisory / Counseling Services

When Community Ownership Isn't Enough: The Uncertain Future of GlenWyvis Distillery

The Highland distillery was built with the support of thousands of people who wanted to create something lasting for their community.  Its entry into administration exposes the financial risks facing ambitious local ventures, even when the original idea has widespread public support.  

8/10/2026 : Advisory / Counseling Services

Innovation and AI: New opportunities for businesses across the Highlands and Islands

Innovation has always been a defining characteristic of businesses and social enterprises in the Highlands and Islands.   Whether developing new products, finding ways to overcome the challenges of distance and geography, improving services, or identifying new markets, organisations across the region have a long track record of adapting and evolving.  

30/9/2026 : Local Authority

Scottish Cities Alliance Investment Conference to showcase Highland opportunities

Inverness will welcome government representatives, investors, business leaders and economic development partners later this week as it hosts the Scottish Cities Alliance Autumn Investor Event.  A two-day programme designed to showcase investment opportunities across Inverness, the Highlands and Scotland's city regions.