Scotland's Public Services Face a Financial Squeeze: Are Council and NHS Cuts Now Inevitable?

Submitted by Bill Fernie

22nd November 2026

Scotland's councils and NHS health boards are approaching another difficult round of budget decisions. Many are already struggling to balance their books, having spent several years absorbing rising costs, increasing demand and funding that has not always kept pace with inflation.

Now they face another combination of pressures. Energy, food, transport, building maintenance, wages and borrowing costs all affect their budgets. At the same time, the Scottish Government has its own financial constraints and cannot simply provide whatever additional money councils and health boards request.

The important question is not simply whether cuts are coming. It is whether Scotland's public services can continue to operate effectively when almost every part of the system is being asked to deliver more with limited resources.

There is a particular danger that apparent savings in one part of government simply transfer costs to another. Reducing preventative services, for example, may save money today but create much larger bills for the NHS or social care in future.

Councils have already made substantial savings

Audit Scotland has repeatedly warned that local government finances are becoming increasingly difficult to sustain.

Councils have already made substantial savings through restructuring, reducing staff numbers, closing buildings, changing services and increasing charges. However, the opportunities for finding relatively painless savings are becoming more limited.

The Highland Council provides a particularly useful example.

On 29 October, the Council announced that it needed to find a further £39.2 million in savings over the next three years to balance its financial plan. This comes on top of £32.8 million in savings and other budget measures already agreed for 2027/28 and 2028/29.

The Council says the additional pressure is largely driven by rising costs and wider economic events, including inflation and higher interest rates. It also warned that early indications suggested its next Scottish Government funding settlement could be lower than previously anticipated, potentially even below a flat-cash position.

The scale of the change is striking. Highland Council's projected budget gap had stood at £5 million in March. By October, it had risen to £39.2 million.

The Council is now consulting residents, businesses, community organisations and young people about its priorities. The final budget decisions are expected on 4 March 2027.

This is important because Highland is not an isolated case. Councils throughout Scotland are facing similar pressures, although their individual circumstances differ.

The Scottish Government has its own financial problem

The Scottish Government cannot simply solve the problem by increasing grants to councils.

It has to balance its own spending commitments against the funding available from Westminster, devolved tax revenues and other income.

The Scottish Fiscal Commission has warned that the Government's efficiency plans depend heavily on savings being delivered across public services.

Its September assessment highlighted that almost half of the planned efficiency savings over the spending review period are expected to come from NHS boards achieving recurring savings of around 3% annually.

However, historical performance raises questions about whether this is realistic. Audit Scotland's evidence showed that only 15% of territorial health boards and 37.5% of special boards achieved their 3% savings targets in 2024/25.

The Fiscal Commission also highlighted the Government's ambition to reduce the devolved public-sector workforce by an average of 0.5% annually between 2025/26 and 2029/30.

These are substantial changes, and the financial consequences will become clearer in the Scottish Budget for 2027/28.

The difficulty is that protecting one area of spending may mean reducing another. Health, education, social security and local government all have strong claims on the available money.

Health boards face an equally difficult challenge

The NHS has a slightly different financial problem. Demand for healthcare does not conveniently stop when the budget runs out.

Hospitals operate around the clock and require heating, electricity, catering, laundry, cleaning, transport and medical supplies. Staff costs represent a substantial proportion of their budgets, while an ageing population and growing demand for treatment add further pressure.

Health boards are being expected to deliver recurring savings while improving waiting times and maintaining services.

There are several possible consequences.

Recruitment restrictions, vacant posts left unfilled, reduced temporary staffing and changes to working arrangements may all reduce expenditure.

Hospital managers may look at reducing bed numbers, shortening stays and moving more patients into community care. This is sensible in principle, but only if adequate community services exist.

Waiting lists may remain longer than patients would wish, while maintenance and replacement programmes for buildings and equipment could be postponed.

The problem is that many of these measures have already been tried.

There is also a connection between NHS and council finances that deserves greater attention. If councils cannot provide sufficient home care and support, patients may remain in hospital longer than necessary. This costs the NHS money and reduces the availability of hospital beds.

Cutting one service can therefore increase the bill somewhere else.

High Life Highland: Savings are already reaching local services

The financial pressures facing Highland Council are not just an accounting exercise. They are beginning to have implications for organisations delivering services directly to communities.

High Life Highland is an important example.

Established by Highland Council in 2011, the charitable organisation delivers a wide range of services on the Council's behalf, including libraries, archives, museums, community centres, countryside rangers, music development, sport and physical activity, and visitor attractions.

It operates leisure facilities and cultural services across a very large geographical area, including communities in Caithness and Sutherland.

At its meeting on 19 November 2026, Highland Council's Corporate Resources Committee considered an updated financial report from High Life Highland.

The report confirmed that the organisation is committed to delivering £516,000 in savings over three years, agreed by the Council in March 2026.

High Life Highland's underlying operations are forecasting an adverse financial variance of approximately £254,000 for 2026/27. The main pressures include staffing costs above budget, planned staffing savings not being achieved and membership income falling below expectations.

The organisation is responding by seeking additional income, reducing other operating costs, using reserves and adjusting opening hours at some sites where opportunities arise.

That last point deserves attention.

The report does not announce specific library closures, but changes to opening hours are one way that savings can affect the availability of local services without a formal announcement that a facility is closing.

For rural communities, even a relatively small reduction in opening hours can matter. A library may be much more than somewhere to borrow books. It can provide internet access, help with digital services, a meeting place and an important community facility.

High Life Highland also has to generate a substantial proportion of its own income. For 2026/27, it expects to deliver approximately £36.16 million in services, with £16.96 million coming from the Council's management fee and the remaining £19.20 million generated through its own activities.

Its charitable status as an arm's-length organisation also saves Highland Council approximately £2.5 million annually through non-domestic rates relief.

There is a further financial complication involving the Inverness Castle Experience, which is accounted for separately from High Life Highland's other services. The latest report forecasts a £1.255 million deficit for the attraction in 2026/27, excluding rent due to the Council. Its visitor numbers and income have been significantly below the assumptions made in the original business plan.

The Council and High Life Highland are reviewing its operating model and looking at ways to reduce costs and increase income.

The wider lesson is that even organisations designed to deliver council services more efficiently are not immune to financial pressures.

High Life Highland has achieved considerable savings and expanded its activities over the years. However, it cannot indefinitely absorb reductions in council funding without considering what that means for facilities, staffing and the services available to local people.

Energy, food and interest rates add another layer

Public services are particularly exposed to rising operating costs.

Hospitals, schools, care homes and leisure facilities consume considerable amounts of energy. They also need food, cleaning materials, transport and regular maintenance.

Higher fuel prices affect ambulances, community nursing, home-care visits and council refuse collection.

Higher food prices affect school meals, hospital catering and residential care.

Interest rates also matter, particularly for councils with substantial borrowing commitments.

Borrowing is used to build and maintain schools, housing, roads and other infrastructure. When interest rates rise, new borrowing and refinancing become more expensive.

There is a difficult choice between postponing investment and allowing buildings and infrastructure to deteriorate, or borrowing more and accepting higher financing costs.

Postponing maintenance can produce an immediate saving, but it does not remove the eventual bill. In some cases, the final repair becomes considerably more expensive.

How will public services cope?]/b]

There are several approaches councils and health boards are likely to use together.

Recruitment restrictions and vacancies can reduce staffing costs, but increase pressure on remaining employees.

Reduced opening hours, fewer local facilities and changes to service provision can produce savings, but may make public services less accessible.

Increased charges can generate additional income, although they also transfer some of the financial pressure to households already facing higher living costs.

Councils may look at sharing administrative services, combining procurement, using technology and restructuring how services are delivered.

Some of these changes can produce genuine efficiencies. However, merging organisations does not automatically save money. There can be substantial initial costs, disruption and additional management requirements.

There is also a danger that centralisation makes services less accessible in rural areas.

For somewhere like Caithness, this deserves particular attention. A saving achieved by moving a service further south may look attractive in an administrative budget, but the consequences for patients and families travelling long distances can be considerable.

[b]Is prevention the answer?


The Scottish Government has been talking increasingly about preventative spending.

The argument is straightforward. It is better to prevent illness, homelessness, family difficulties and other problems than to pay for expensive interventions after they have become serious.

There is considerable logic in this approach.

However, preventative services often require investment now to produce savings later. When budgets are under immediate pressure, these are sometimes among the first services to be reduced because the financial benefits are not immediately visible.

That can be a false economy.

Reducing community support may increase pressure on hospitals. Reducing early intervention may increase demand for social work and other services. Allowing housing problems to worsen can create much larger costs for councils and the NHS.

The challenge is to protect spending that genuinely reduces future demand, rather than simply treating every preventative programme as automatically worthwhile.

What should we look for in the next Scottish Budget?

The Scottish Budget for 2027/28 will be an important test of the Government's ability to reconcile its political promises with the money actually available.

There are several things worth watching.

How much additional money will be allocated to local government, and will it represent a genuine increase after inflation?

Will health boards receive realistic budgets, or simply be instructed to find another round of savings?

Will social care receive sufficient funding to reduce pressure on hospitals?

Will capital spending be protected, or will schools, hospitals, roads and other public assets continue to deteriorate through postponed maintenance?

Finally, will ministers and councils be honest about the services that may have to be reduced?

There is little value in announcing that services are being protected if the money allocated cannot actually deliver them.

Scotland needs an honest discussion about public services

I think we should expect further reductions in public services, although they may not always be announced as cuts.

Instead, they may appear as fewer staff, reduced opening hours, longer waiting times, delayed maintenance, increased charges and services that gradually become less available.

These changes can happen incrementally, with no single decision attracting much attention, until their cumulative effect becomes very noticeable.

The danger is that councils and health boards end up managing their immediate budgets at the expense of the longer-term financial position.

Scotland needs a much more honest discussion about what public services can realistically provide with the money available.

There is no point in politicians promising to protect everything when the financial arithmetic suggests otherwise.

And perhaps the most important question is whether the next budget will tackle the underlying problems or simply move the financial difficulties into another year.

For communities across the Highlands, the consequences will not be measured in budget statements or percentage savings. They will be measured in whether the local library remains open, whether a leisure centre can continue to operate, whether home care is available when needed and whether people can access NHS services without travelling ever greater distances.

 

Related Businesses

 

Related Articles

19/11/2026 : Local Authority

UK Shared Prosperity Fund investment helps grow green skills in the Highlands

Investment through the UK Shared Prosperity Fund is helping UHI Inverness expand access to green skills training and new technologies, supporting the workforce needed for the Highlands' transition to a low carbon economy.   A total of £220,000 of UK Shared Prosperity Fund support has been awarded towards a £234,000 programme, covering three linked projects: green skills training, Solar PV installation, and the purchase of augmented and virtual reality welding equipment.  

17/11/2026 : Local Authority

New Members of the Scottish Youth Parliament elected for Highland

The Scottish Youth Parliament (SYP) has welcomed five new Highland members and one continuing member following the outcome of recent elections.   Members of the Scottish Youth Parliament (MSYP) are elected every two years and become the voice of Scotland's young people.  

16/11/2026 : Advisory / Counseling Services

The People Building Caithness's Future: Meet the Local Entrepreneurs Making Things Happen

When people discuss the future of Caithness, attention often turns to major employers, government investment, renewable energy developments and the search for new industries.   All of these matter.  

16/11/2026 : Local Authority

Caithness Has More to Celebrate Than We Sometimes Realise

Caithness has become accustomed to reading about economic difficulties, declining public services, empty shops, rising costs and the challenges facing rural communities.  These are important issues and should not be ignored.  

16/11/2026 : Local Authority

The Subscription Society: Are Councils and Publicly Funded Charities Charging Us for Too Much?

Councils across Scotland are under considerable financial pressure.  Rising wages, energy bills, borrowing costs and increasing demand for essential services are leaving local authorities searching for ways to balance their budgets.  

15/11/2026 : Local Authority

Caithness: Are We Becoming Britain's Energy Storage Capital?

Caithness has long been associated with energy production.  From the nuclear industry at Dounreay to the development of onshore wind farms, the area has played an important role in Britain's changing energy requirements.  

15/11/2026 : Local Authority

Highland Rangers Do Valuable Work, But Is a Paid Newsletter the Best Use of Their Time?

Highland's Countryside Ranger Service performs an important role in protecting the natural environment, helping people understand local wildlife and encouraging greater appreciation of the countryside.  Its work with schools, communities, visitors and landowners is valuable, and at a time when environmental pressures are increasing, the contribution of Rangers should not be underestimated.  

15/11/2026 : Local Authority

Caithness at a Crossroads: Investment Opportunities Grow, But Are Essential Services Keeping Pace?

Caithness finds itself in an interesting position.  There are opportunities emerging across energy, infrastructure, harbour development, education and construction.  

14/11/2026 : Local Authority

Highland's £2.1 Billion Investment Gamble: Rising Interest Rates, Construction Costs and Energy Prices Create New Risks

Highland Council's ambitious 20-year investment programme was designed to modernise schools, roads and public buildings.  But higher borrowing costs, construction inflation and rising energy prices are raising questions about whether the original financial assumptions will still stand up.  

13/11/2026 : Local Authority

Almost £500,000 awarded to community transport groups across the Highlands

Community transport groups across the Highlands have been awarded grants totalling £498,000 to support local transport services in 2027/28.   The grants will support 34 community transport providers, including seven new recipients, whose services play a vital role in helping people access services, connecting communities and addressing local transport challenges.