When Tourists Take the Homes: Is Europe Losing Its Housing to Tourism?

6th October 2026

Tens of thousands of people have been protesting across Spain over the country's housing crisis, with rapidly rising rents and the growing influence of tourism among their biggest concerns.

The protests came after the Spanish parliament rejected government measures intended to strengthen tenant protection and restrict some forms of short-term rental accommodation.

The immediate political dispute is Spanish.

But the underlying problem is much wider.

Across Europe, popular tourist destinations are increasingly facing the same awkward question:

How much housing can be turned into holiday accommodation before local people begin to struggle to find somewhere to live?

And Scotland is not immune.

Spain is the most visible example

Spain has become the latest European country where housing and tourism have collided dramatically.

Tens of thousands of people demonstrated in more than 50 cities after parliament rejected two government measures aimed at tackling the housing crisis. Average rents in Spain have almost doubled over the past decade, while house prices have also risen sharply. (euronews.com)

Tourism is not the only reason.

Spain has a shortage of housing in many areas, rising demand, investment in property and demographic pressures.

But short-term holiday accommodation has become part of the argument.

A property that might previously have been rented to a local family for a year can potentially generate considerably more income if it is rented to tourists for short stays.

That creates an obvious economic incentive for owners.

But it also creates an obvious problem for residents.

And this is not just a Spanish problem

The European Commission now recognises that housing pressures are particularly severe in cities, islands and tourist destinations.

Its work on the European Affordable Housing Plan specifically identifies situations where demand significantly exceeds supply and says that some forms of non-primary use of housing can make it harder for people to find long-term homes. (ec.europa.eu)

The European Commission's economic analysis also identifies the expansion of short-term rentals as one of several factors contributing to housing demand, alongside urbanisation, demographic change and investment.

But there is an important warning here.

Short-term lets are not the whole explanation for Europe's housing crisis.

Housing supply, construction costs, population changes, household size, incomes, mortgage rates and investment all matter.

The European Commission's research says rents for new contracts have risen substantially in many parts of Europe while housing supply has struggled to keep pace. (ec.europa.eu)

So it would be too simple to blame Airbnb or tourism for everything.

But tourism can change the economics of a property

There is nevertheless a very straightforward calculation behind the problem.

If a property owner can earn more by renting to visitors for a few nights at a time than by offering it to a local household for a month, the financial incentive is obvious.

The OECD's latest tourism report gives an interesting example from Ireland.

Research found that, on average, a property in coastal areas only needed to be rented for around 6–8 days a month as a short-term holiday let to match the revenue from a month in the private rental market.

In Dublin, the equivalent figure was around 8–10 days.

That doesn't mean every Airbnb property would otherwise become a long-term rental.

The OECD specifically warns that the relationship is complicated.

But it demonstrates why tourism can change the economics of residential property. (oecd.org)

Europe is beginning to respond

The EU has recognised that governments need better information about the short-term rental market.

New European rules are being applied to improve transparency and data sharing.

In 2025, guests spent 951.6 million nights in short-term rental accommodation booked through online platforms across the EU.

That is an enormous industry.

The new framework is intended to give public authorities much better information about where these properties are, how often they are being used and whether operators are complying with local rules. (ec.europa.eu)

And different cities are beginning to take very different approaches.

Some are restricting the number of days properties can be rented.

Others are introducing registration systems.

Some require planning permission.

Others are restricting short-term lets in particular neighbourhoods.

The underlying argument is becoming increasingly familiar:

Tourism brings money and jobs, but residents also need somewhere to live.

Scotland has already recognised the problem

Scotland is actually ahead of much of the UK in one respect.

The Scottish Government introduced a licensing system for short-term lets, and local authorities have powers to establish short-term-let control areas.

The latest official statistics are striking.

At the end of 2025 there were 32,317 short-term-let licences or exemptions in operation across Scotland.

And 78% of active licences related to properties that were not the operator's primary residence.

That is important.

Most of Scotland's short-term-let activity covered by the licensing system isn't simply somebody occasionally renting out their spare bedroom.

There are substantial numbers of properties being operated as secondary accommodation.

Across Scotland there were 118 active short-term lets per 10,000 dwellings.

But that national average is potentially misleading.

Because some communities have vastly higher concentrations.

The rural and island problem is much bigger

In Na h-Eileanan Siar, there were 707 short-term lets per 10,000 dwellings.

The figure in East Renfrewshire was only 10.

That is an enormous difference.

It demonstrates why a national average can hide what is happening in individual communities. (gov.scot)

This is particularly important for Scotland's islands, Highlands and other tourist destinations.

A village does not need thousands of Airbnb properties before the effect becomes noticeable.

If a community has only a few hundred houses, even a relatively small number being converted to holiday accommodation can make a significant difference to the number of homes available to local residents.

And the people most affected may be those with the least ability to compete financially.

Young people.

Key workers.

Nurses.

Teachers.

Care workers.

Police officers.

People working in hotels and restaurants.

The very people needed to operate the tourism economy can find themselves unable to afford to live in the tourist destination.

That is a strange economic circle.

Scotland's own Government acknowledges the problem

This isn't simply a claim made by housing campaigners.

The Scottish Government's 2026 guidance for local housing strategies explicitly says that second homes, particularly when concentrated in particular areas, can reduce the supply of permanent homes.

It also says that second homes can operate as short-term lets and that both can contribute to local housing pressures, including difficulties in providing homes for key workers.

The guidance acknowledges that short-term lets bring economic benefits through tourism and jobs, but says that high concentrations can be problematic. (gov.scot)

That is a fairly important admission.

The Scottish Government is effectively saying that tourism accommodation can compete with housing for local people.

Highland Council is now looking at the issue

The issue is particularly relevant in Highland.

Highland Council has been considering short-term-let control areas in parts of the Highlands where the concentration of holiday accommodation is creating concerns about housing and community sustainability.

This is not necessarily an argument against tourism.

Highland depends heavily on tourism.

The visitor economy supports accommodation, restaurants, shops, attractions, transport and thousands of jobs.

But tourism also requires people to live locally to provide those services.

That creates the paradox.

A place can become so successful as a tourist destination that the people needed to run the tourist economy can no longer afford to live there.

The evidence is complicated

There is an important qualification.

It would be wrong to claim that every short-term let represents a home that would otherwise have housed a local family.

Some properties have always been holiday homes.

Some owners would never have entered the long-term rental market.

Some areas have more vacant and second homes than they can realistically use for permanent housing.

And tourism can bring significant economic benefits.

The OECD says the evidence linking short-term rentals directly to housing problems is mixed and that the relationship is difficult to prove conclusively.

Research in Ireland, for example, found no clear relationship between increases in Airbnb activity and falls in new private tenancies at local level.

So we shouldn't turn a complicated housing problem into a simple "Airbnb is to blame" argument.

But concentration matters

This may be the most important point.

A national figure can suggest that short-term lets are relatively small compared with the total housing stock.

The experience of a particular village can be completely different.

The OECD notes that short-term rentals account for around 1.2% of the EU's overall housing stock, but some coastal and rural tourism destinations and particular urban neighbourhoods have substantially higher concentrations. (oecd.org)

This is why the argument increasingly becomes local rather than national.

If 1% of homes in a huge city become tourist accommodation, the impact may be difficult to see.

If 10%, 15% or 20% of the housing in a small community is unavailable for permanent residents, the consequences could be much more obvious.

Scotland therefore faces a difficult balancing act

There are really two legitimate economic arguments.

The first says:

Tourism creates jobs, income and economic activity. Don't strangle it.

The second says:

A community cannot survive if the people who live and work there cannot find homes.

Neither argument can simply be dismissed.

And this is where Scotland's approach of giving councils more information and planning powers becomes important.

Perhaps the answer isn't a blanket ban on holiday lets.

Perhaps it is identifying communities where the concentration has become too high and giving local authorities the ability to intervene.

That is broadly the direction Scotland has been taking.

Could Britain eventually see Spanish-style protests?

That may be the more interesting question.

Scotland has not experienced anything on the scale of the current Spanish demonstrations.

And Scotland's rental market is behaving differently from Spain's.

The latest ONS figures show Scottish average private rents at £1,013 a month in August 2026, up only 1.1% over the year. In Highland and Islands, however, average rents were £739, up 4.3%, with one-bedroom rents rising 5.2%.

The numbers therefore don't suggest a Scotland-wide Spanish-style rental explosion at present.

But averages again conceal local pressures.

And that is exactly why the Highlands and islands deserve attention.

The question Scotland may eventually have to answer

Tourism is one of Scotland's great economic assets.

But housing is one of the basic requirements for a functioning society.

The two should complement each other.

They shouldn't compete to the point where one undermines the other.

If too many houses become holiday accommodation, local people struggle to find homes.

If too many restrictions are imposed, tourism businesses may struggle to find accommodation for visitors and investment may fall.

There is no magic number that works everywhere.

But perhaps there is a simple test for every tourist community:

Can the people who work here still afford to live here?

If the answer eventually becomes no, then the tourism success story has created a rather serious problem of its own.

Spain's protests are a warning that housing can move from being a technical policy issue to becoming a major political issue very quickly.

Scotland may not be at that point.

But with more than 32,000 licensed or exempt short-term lets, and with concentrations vastly higher in some island and rural communities, it would be unwise to assume that the question is going away.

The challenge is not choosing between tourists and residents.

It is finding a way for both to have a future.

 

Related Businesses

 

Related Articles

Today : Advisory / Counseling Services

The People Building Caithness's Future: Meet the Local Entrepreneurs Making Things Happen

When people discuss the future of Caithness, attention often turns to major employers, government investment, renewable energy developments and the search for new industries.   All of these matter.  

Today : Local Authority

Caithness Has More to Celebrate Than We Sometimes Realise

Caithness has become accustomed to reading about economic difficulties, declining public services, empty shops, rising costs and the challenges facing rural communities.  These are important issues and should not be ignored.  

Today : Local Authority

The Subscription Society: Are Councils and Publicly Funded Charities Charging Us for Too Much?

Councils across Scotland are under considerable financial pressure.  Rising wages, energy bills, borrowing costs and increasing demand for essential services are leaving local authorities searching for ways to balance their budgets.  

Yesterday : Local Authority

Caithness: Are We Becoming Britain's Energy Storage Capital?

Caithness has long been associated with energy production.  From the nuclear industry at Dounreay to the development of onshore wind farms, the area has played an important role in Britain's changing energy requirements.  

Yesterday : Local Authority

Highland Rangers Do Valuable Work, But Is a Paid Newsletter the Best Use of Their Time?

Highland's Countryside Ranger Service performs an important role in protecting the natural environment, helping people understand local wildlife and encouraging greater appreciation of the countryside.  Its work with schools, communities, visitors and landowners is valuable, and at a time when environmental pressures are increasing, the contribution of Rangers should not be underestimated.  

Yesterday : Local Authority

Caithness at a Crossroads: Investment Opportunities Grow, But Are Essential Services Keeping Pace?

Caithness finds itself in an interesting position.  There are opportunities emerging across energy, infrastructure, harbour development, education and construction.  

14/11/2026 : Local Authority

Highland's £2.1 Billion Investment Gamble: Rising Interest Rates, Construction Costs and Energy Prices Create New Risks

Highland Council's ambitious 20-year investment programme was designed to modernise schools, roads and public buildings.  But higher borrowing costs, construction inflation and rising energy prices are raising questions about whether the original financial assumptions will still stand up.  

13/11/2026 : Local Authority

Almost £500,000 awarded to community transport groups across the Highlands

Community transport groups across the Highlands have been awarded grants totalling £498,000 to support local transport services in 2027/28.   The grants will support 34 community transport providers, including seven new recipients, whose services play a vital role in helping people access services, connecting communities and addressing local transport challenges.  

11/11/2026 : Local Authority

High Life Highland Shows What Can Be Achieved: £43 Million in Council Savings While Expanding Services Across the Highlands

Highland Council is facing continuing financial pressures, with difficult decisions about services, staffing, facilities and future investment.  Yet one organisation delivering a substantial range of council services appears to have found a way of expanding its reach while reducing its reliance on council funding.  

11/11/2026 : Local Authority

Highland Education Budget: A Modest Overspend Hides Some Much Bigger Financial Problems

Special schools, pressure on individual school budgets, delayed savings and growing costs of additional support raise questions about how sustainable Highland Council's education finances really are.   At first glance, Highland Council's latest Education and Learning budget monitoring report might not appear particularly alarming.